Rozwój sieci bankomatów w Polsce a opłaty interchange i surcharge

• Autorzy: Jakub Górka

Warianty tytułu

ATM Network Development in Poland and ATM Interchange and Surcharge Fees

• Języki publikacji: PL

Abstrakty

Celem artykułu jest ocena wpływu na rozwój sieci bankomatowej w Polsce wprowadzonych w 2010 r. obniżek opłaty interchange od transakcji wypłaty gotówki w bankomatach w systemach Visa i MasterCard oraz analiza zasadności umożliwienia nakładania opłaty dodatkowej (surcharge) na wypłaty gotówki przez właścicieli urządzeń ATM (Automated Teller Machine). Ponadto na podstawie autorskich badań w artykule przedstawiono szacunkowe oszczędności, jakie użycie bankomatów niesie klientom i bankom w Polsce. Zostały określone czasowe korzyści konsumentów oraz pieniężne oszczędności banków i gospodarki polskiej w 2009 r.(fragment tekstu)

EN

The article sets out to assess the development of Poland's network of automated teller machines (ATMs) after a series of reductions in ATM interchange fees in the Visa and MasterCard systems in 2010. The author aims to determine how these reductions have influenced the development of the country's cash dispenser network and analyzes whether or not ATM owners should be allowed to impose special surcharges on cash withdrawals under law. Moreover, based on empirical research conducted in 2010 and 2009, the author estimates the savings for consumers and banks resulting from the use of ATMs. Thanks to cash dispensers, consumers save time, while banks and the economy as a whole save money, Górka notes. The research makes use of foreign market experience, especially that gained in the United States, and of theoretical models developed in various research reports. The specific features of the Polish market are also taken into account. The author outlines the advantages and disadvantages of ATM surcharges, pointing out that, under the current economic conditions in Poland, following the interchange fee reductions, passing laws regulating the permissibility of surcharges would be beneficial to the development of the country's ATM network, especially in rural areas and small towns. The development of the ATM network benefits both consumers and banks, the author says. Poland is a country in which cash payments continue to dominate and consumers need to have access to banknotes and coins, while cash dispensers are a relatively cheap channel of distributing cash, Górka says. Based on macroeconomic data for 2009, the author estimates that Polish consumers saved 22.4 million hours that year by withdrawing cash in ATMs instead of at bank branches, which means that the average consumer and bank product user saved 1 hour. The total cost savings of the Polish economy from the use of ATMs stood at 1.63 billion zlotys (about 400 million euros). The estimated cost savings for banks were 1.34 billion zlotys (around 340 million euros), according to Górka. An analysis of the Polish market data shows that the reductions in the interchange fees collected from ATM cash withdrawal transactions have directly led to a sharp decline in the profitability of the ATM business for banks and independent ATM deployers, who have recently been the main driving force behind the development of the ATM network in Poland. In the case of Poland, the possibility of charging special ATM transaction convenience fees does not necessarily mean that such fees will be charged to consumers, while they would help stimulate the market, according to the author. At the moment, interchange fees are low, Górka says, which discourages both banks and independent ATM deployers from investing in the development of the ATM network despite consumer expectations.(original abstract)

Słowa kluczowe

PL

Bankomaty; Karty płatnicze; Operacje bankowe

EN

Cash machine; Payment cards; Banking transactions

• Czasopismo: Gospodarka Narodowa
• Rocznik: 2011
• Numer: nr 7-8
• Strony: 89--112

Twórcy

autor

Jakub Górka

• Uniwersytet Warszawski

Bibliografia

• Bank Portugalii (Banco de Portugal), [2007], Retail Payment Instruments in Portugal: Costs and Benefits, Study.
• Bergman M., Guibourg G., Segendorf B., [2007], The Costs of Paying - Private and Social Costs of Cash and Card Payments, Sveriges Riksbank Working Paper Series 212.
• Bradbury J., ATM Surcharges and the Expansion of Consumer Choice, [1998], CATO Institute Briefing Papers, Paper No. 36, March 19.
• Bruce L., [2009], Bank ATM Surcharges Leap, Bankrate 2009 Checking Study, www.bankrate.com.
• Chioveanu I., Fauli-Oller R., Sandonis J., Santamaria J., [2009], ATM Surcharges: Effects on Deployment and Welfare, "Journal of Industrial Economics" Vol. 57 Issue 3, pp. 613-635.
• Croft E., Spencer B., [2003], Fees and Surcharging in Automatic Teller Machine Networks: Nonbank ATM providers versus Large Banks, National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper 9883, Cambridge.
• Enge A., Øwre G., [2006], A retrospective on the introduction of prices in the Norwegian Payment System, Economic Bulletin Norges Bank, Vol. 77, No. 4, pp. 162-172.
• Gamble R., [2008], The ATM Fee Decision, "Credit Union Management", Vol. 31, Issue 4, pp. 44-48.
• Gowrisankaran G., Krainer J., [2005], The Welfare Consequences of ATM Surcharges: Evidence from a Structural Entry Model, Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, Working Paper 2005-01.
• Górka J., [2009], Konkurencyjność form pieniądza i instrumentów płatniczych, CeDeWu, Warszawa.
• Górka J., [2010], Opłaty dodatkowe (surcharging) na rynku płatności, w: Partycki S. (red.), "Partnerstwo i współpraca a kryzys gospodarczo-społeczny w Europie Środkowej i Wschodniej", Wydawnictwo KUL, Lublin, tom I, s. 667:680.
• De Grauwe P., Rinaldi L., Van Cayseele P., [2006], Issuess of efficiency in the use of cash and cards, University of Leuven, Working Paper.
• Gresvik O., Haare H., [2009], Costs in the payment system, Norges Bank Economic Bulletin, Vol. 80, No. 1, pp. 16-27.
• Hannan T., [2007], ATM Surcharge Bans and Bank Market Structure: The Case of Iowa and Its Neighbors, "Journal of Banking and Finance", Vol. 31, Issue 4, pp. 1061-1082.
• Hannan T., Kiser E., Prager R., McAndrews J., [2003], To surcharge or not to surcharge: An empirical investigation of ATM pricing, "Review of Economics and Statistics", Vol. 85, No. 4, pp. 990-1002.
• Humphrey D., Bolt W., Uittenbogaard R., [2008], Transaction Pricing and the Adoption of Electronic Payments: A Cross-Country Comparison, "International Journal of Central Banking", Vol. 4, No. 1, pp. 89-123.
• Humphrey D., [1994], Delivering deposit services: ATMs versus branches, "Economic Quarterly", Issue Spring, pp. 59-81.
• Ishii J., [2005], Interconnection Pricing, Compatibility, and Investment in Network Industries: ATM Networks in the Banking Industry, Working Paper, Stanford University.
• Keenan C., [March 20006], Putting the CINCH on ATM Costs, Community Banker, Vol. 15, Issue 3, pp. 40-43.
• Knittel C., Stango V., [2008], Incompatibility, Product Attributes and Consumer Welfare: Evidence from ATMs, Berkeley Electronic Press, "Journal of Economic Analysis and Policy", Vol. 8, Issue 1, pp. 1-40.
• Leinonen H. (ed.), [2008], Payment habits and trends in the changing e-landscape 2010+, Expository Studies, Bank of Finland, A: 111.
• Lepecq G., [2008], The Future of Cash, Report, Agis Consulting, Scan Coin, Innovia Security.
• POFOG, [2009], Obrót gotówkowy - przyszłość rynku w Polsce, Raport, Warszawa.
• Massoud N., Saunders A., Scholnick B., [2006], The Impact of ATM Surcharges on Large versus Small Banks: Is There a Switching Effect? "Journal of Business", 79, 4, pp. 2099-2125.
• Massoud N., Bernhardt D., [2002], Rip-Off' ATM Surcharges, "RAND Journal of Economics", Vol. 33, No. 1, pp. 96-115.
• McAndrews J., [1998], ATM Surcharges, Federal Reserve Bank of New York, "Current Issues in Economics and Finance", Vol. 4, No. 4.
• McAndrews J., [2003], Automated Teller Machine Network Pricing - A Review of the Literature, "Review of Network Economics" Vol. 2, Issue 2, pp. 146-158.
• McKinsey Report, [2008], Denecker O., Istace F., Van Oostende M., ATMs: Complex weapons in the war on cash, McKinsey on Payments.
• Narodowy Bank Polski, Związek Banków Polskich, Koalicja Na Rzecz Rozwoju Obrotu Bezgotówkowego i Mikropłatności, [2010], Program rozwoju obrotu bezgotówkowego na lata 2010-2013, Warszawa (projekt z dnia 8 czerwca).
• Narodowy Bank Polski, [2011], Informacja o kartach płatniczych IV kwartał 2010 r., Warszawa.
• Prager B., [2001], The Effects of Surcharges on Small Banking Organizations, (SpringerLink) "Review of Industrial Organisation" Vol 18, Issue 2, pp. 161-173.
• Stavins J., [2000], ATM Fees: Does Bank Size Matter?, "New England Economic Review", Issue January/February, pp. 13-24.
• TNS OBOP badania, [2010], Polacy o korzystaniu z bankomatów.
• Van Hove L., [2008], On the War On Cash and its spoils, "International Journal of Electronic Banking", Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 36-45.
• www.atmia.com
• www.euronetworldwide.com, www.euronetpolska.pl
• www.wikipedia.org (ATM, ATM usage fees, etc)
• www.karty.pl
• Aktualne wiadomości gospodarcze, m.in. z www.bankier.pl, www.prnews.pl, www.wyborcza.biz, itp.
• Bazy danych Europejskiego Banku Centralnego (ECB), Banku Rozrachunków Międzynarodowych (BIS), Narodowego Banku Polskiego (NBP) i Głównego Urzędu Statystycznego (GUS).