Geneza Europejskiego Rzecznika Praw Obywatelskich

• Autorzy: Paweł Sadowski

Warianty tytułu

The Origin of the European Ombudsman

• Języki publikacji: PL

Abstrakty

W artykule omówiono ideę obywatelstwa europejskiego i jego wpływ na powstanie instytucji Europejskiego Rzecznika Praw Obywatelskich. Przedstawiono również propozycje hiszpańskiego premiera włączenia do nowego traktatu oddzielnego rozdziału poświęconego obywatelstwu europejskiemu oraz koncepcje zaproponowane przez Hiszpanię i Danię w zakresie ochrony praw obywateli.

EN

Assumption of the Treaty about the European Union of 7 February 1992 opened an important chapter in the sphere of the community regulation of the status of citizens of the European Union and its institutional reforms. The treaty constituted the legal construction of the citizenship of the European Union and the consequent rights, which had to be protected by judicial and extrajudicial mechanisms, among them, the institution of the European Ombudsman deserves special attention. The idea of the appointment of the institution of the Ombudsman on the community level was enrolled into experiences in many member countries from which it resulted, i.e. the independent institution like ombudsman, can create the elastic and effective system of the controlling of authorities, warranting that the right is justly practical and protects citizens. This was especially essential in consideration of the fact that the first economic integration and the further enlargement of the competence had gone toward the more and more deeper integration, both legal and political. Further development and the evolution of Commonwealths could not follow separately from citizens and their composite needs, and this manner it was necessary to acknowledge to them additional rights, entering into the range of the new institution of the European citizenship. In the article there was introduced the idea of the European citizenship and its influence on the origin of the European Ombudsman, and also two ideas of the institution of Ombudsman effluent from Danish and Spanish experiences.(original abstract)

Słowa kluczowe

PL

Prawa obywatelskie; Rzecznik Praw Obywatelskich; Obywatelstwo UE

EN

Civil Rights; Ombudsman; Citizenship of the European Union

• Czasopismo: Studia Iuridica Lublinensia
• Rocznik: 2014
• Tom: 22
• Strony: 603--629

Twórcy

autor

Paweł Sadowski

Bibliografia

• D. Olivier, D. Heater, The Foundations of Citizenship, New York-London 1994, s. 133.
• S. Konopacki, Obywatelstwo europejskie w kontekście członkostwa Polski w Unii Europejskiej, Łódź 2005, s. 68.
• J. M. Sorensen, The Exclusive European Citizenship; The Case of Refugees and Immigrants in the European Union, "International Migration Review" 1998, vol. 32, s. 507-508.
• E. A. Marias, From Market Citizen to Union Citizen, [w:] European Citizenship, red. E. A. Marias, Maastricht 1994, s. 2.
• W. Sadurski, Obywatelstwo europejskie, "Studia Europejskie" 2005, nr 4, s. 32.
• F. Requejo, European Citizenship in Plurinational States - Some Limits of Traditional Democratic Theories: Rawls and Habermas, [w:] European Citizenship, Multiculturalism and the State, red. U. Preuss, F. Requejo, Baden-Baden 1998, s. 29.
• A. Evans, European Citizenship, "Modern Law Review" 1982, vol. 45, s. 496;
• J. Habermas, Die postnationale Konstellation. Politische Essays, Frankfurt am Main 1998, s. 91.
• S. Kadelbach, Union Citizenship, "Jean Monnet Working Paper" 2003, 9, s. 5.
• J. A. Winter, sprawa 11/70 Internationale Handelsgesellschaft mbH przeciwko Einfuhr- und Vorratsstelle fur Getreide und Futtermittel, "Common Market Law Review" 1971, vol. 8, s. 250-263;
• W. Czapliński, R. Ostrihansky, P. Saganek, A. Wyrozumska, Prawo Wspólnot Europejskich. Orzecznictwo, Warszawa 2001, s. 44 i 333.
• G. Meier, Rechtsprechung. Bundesverfassungsgericht. Beschluss vom 29.5.1974, "Neue Juristiche Wochenschrift" 1974, 38.
• U. Scheuner, Fundamental Rights in European Community Law and in national constitutional law, "Common Market Law Review" 1975, vol. 12, s. 171-191.
• M. Dybowski, Prawa fundamentalne w orzecznictwie ETS, Warszawa 2007, s. 8 i n.
• Komisja Europejska, Towards a Europe for citizens, "Biuletyn Wspólnot Europejskich", 7/8 1975, s. 12-14.
• M. Holland, European Integration. From Community to Union, London 1993, s. 61.
• C. Closa, The Concept of Citizenship in the Treaty on the European Union, "Common Market Law Review", vol. 29, 1991, s. 1147.
• M. Lis, Podstawowe instytucje prawa europejskiego - zarys problematyki, [w:] Wspólnoty Europejskie. Wybrane problemy, red. J. Kolas, t. I, Wrocław 1994, s. 45 i n.
• D. Walker-Smith, The Case for a European Ombudsman, London 1978, s. 10 i n.
• B. Boyle, The democratic deficit of the European Community, "Parliamentary Affairs" 1993,vol. 46, s. 458-477;
• A. Jones, Britain and the European Union, Edinburgh University Press, 2007, s. 51 i n.
• R. Corbett, F. Jacobs, M. Shackleton, Parlament Europejski, Rzeszów 1996, s. 301 i n.
• N. Banaszak, Rzecznik obywateli Unii Europejskiej, "Acta Universitatis Wratislaviensis", Przegląd Prawa i Administracji 1998, 41, s. 70-71.
• W. Ungerer, Post-Fontainbleau European Perspectives, "Aussenpolitik" 1984, vol. 35, s. 390-404.
• S. O'Leary, European Union Citizenship. The Option for Reform, London 1996, s. 36.
• P. Wattel, The EC Court's attempts to reconcile the Treaty freedoms with international tax law, "Common Market Law Review" 1996, vol. 33, s. 240.
• R. Rawlings, Engaged elites. Citizen action and institutional attitudes in Commission enforcement, "European Law Journal" 2000, vol. 6, s. 10;
• A. Tomkins, The Enforcement of EC Law [w:] Law and Administration in Europe, red. P. Craig, R. Rawlings, Oxford 2003.
• D. Lasok, The European Communities and the European Union, [w:] Law of the European Communities, D. Vaughan, London 1994, s. 120.
• A. Arnull, Deficyt odpowiedzialności w Unii Europejskiej, [w:] Odpowiedzialność i legitymacja Unii Europejskiej, red. A. Arnull, D. Wincott, Warszawa 2007, s. 30 i n.;
• J. Monar, Proces decyzyjny w przestrzeni wolności, bezpieczeństwa i sprawiedliwości [w:] Odpowiedzialność i legitymacja Unii Europejskiej, red. A. Arnull, D. Wincott, Warszawa 2007s. 74-80.
• J. Shaw, European Citizenship: The IGC and beyond, "European Integration On-line Papers" 1997, 3, s. 1.
• R. Wieruszewski, Obywatelstwo Unii Europejskiej a ochrona praw człowieka, [w:] Polska w Unii Europejskiej, red. M. Kruk, J. Wawrzyniak, Kraków 2005, s. 236;
• R. Davis, Citizenship of the Union...Rights for all?, "European Law Review" 2002, vol. 27, s. 121.
• J. Monar, A dual citizenship in the making: The citizenship of the European Union and its reform, [w:] European Citizenship: An Institutional Challenge, red. M. La Torre, Hague 1998, s. 173.
• J. Shaw, The Interpretation of European Union Citizenship, "Modern Law Review" 1998, vol. 61, s. 295.
• C. Mouffe, Democratic Politics Today, [w:] Dimensions of Radical Democracy, red. C. Mouffe, London 1992;
• A. Wiener, Assessing the Constructive Potential of Union Citizenship - A Socio-Historical Perspective, "European Integration On-line Papers" 1997, 17;
• C. Tilly, Citizenship, Identity and Social History, Cambridge University Press 1996, s. 4-6.
• B. van Steenbergen, The Condition of Citizenship, London 1994, s. 43.
• J. Habermas, The European Nation State. Its Achievements and Its Limitations. On the Past and Future of Sovereignty and Citizenship, "Ratio Juris" 1996, vol. 9, s.125.
• V. Miller, Human Right in the EU: the Charter of Fundamental Rights, "House of Commons Research Paper" 2000, 32, s. 18.
• The Intergovernmental Conference on Political Union, red. F. Laursen, S. Vanhoonacker, Maastricht 1992, s. 269-275;
• C. Gonzalez, The Spanish Proposal to the Intergovernmental Conference on Political Union, [w:] The European Ombudsman. Origins, Establishment, Evolution, s. 28.
• P. Solbes Mira, La citoyenneté européenne, "Revue du marché commun et de l'Union européenne" 1991, vol. 345, s. 168.
• The Spanish proposal for a European Ombudsman, as contained in the Spanish proposal to the Intergovernmental Conference on Political Union, http://ombudsman.europa.eu/historical/pdf/en/3940-90.pdf.
• R. Kovar, D. Simon, La citoyenneté européenne, "Cahiers de droit européenne" 1993, vol. 29, s. 309.
• H. Desfeuilles, Le pouvoir de contrôle des parlements nordiques, Paris 1973;
• K. Weeks, Ombudsman Around the World. A Comparative Chart, Berkeley 1978;
• G. Napione, L'Ombudsman. Il conrole della publica admministrazione, Milan 1969;
• The Ombudsman - Citizen's Defender, red. D. C. Rowat, London-Toronto-Stockholm 1968;
• W. Gelhorn, Ombudsman and the Others. Citizen's Protector in Nine Countries, Cambridge 1967;
• E. Holmberg, N. Stjernquist, Var Forfattining, Stockholm 1983;
• H. Hiden, The Parliamentary Ombudsman in Finland. Position and Function, Helsinki 1976;
• R. Gregory, P. Hutscheson, The Parliamentary Ombudsman. A Study in the Control of Administrative Action, London 1975;
• F. A. Stacey, Ombudsman Compared, Oxford 1978;
• F. A. Stacey, The British Ombudsman, Oxford 1971;
• B. Malignier, Les functions du Mediteur, Paris 1979;
• I. Al-Wahab, The Swedish Institution of Ombudsman, Stockholm 1979.
• D. C. Rowat, The Ombudsman Plan. The Worldwide Spread of the Idea, London 1985, s. 131.
• Righting Wrongs. The Ombudsman in Six Continents, red. R. Gregory, Ph. Giddings, International Institute of Administrative Sciences, 2000.
• Proposal Towards a European Citizenship, wrzesień 1990, dokument zamieszczony, [w:] R. Corbett, The Treaty of Maastricht. From Conception to Ratification. A Comprehensive Reference Guide, London 1993, s. 153.
• P. Sadowski, Skarga do Rzecznika Praw Obywatelskich Unii Europejskiej, "Studia Iuridica Lublinensia" 2006, t. 7, s. 177.
• F. Laursen, op. cit., s. 329; E. A. Marias, The European Ombudsman: Competences and Relations with Other Community Institutions and Bodies, [w:] The European Ombudsman, red. E.A. Marias, Maastricht 1994, s. 73.
• Tekst Konstytucji Królestwa Hiszpanii, [w:] T. Mołdawa, Konstytucja Hiszpanii z 27 grudnia 1978 r., Warszawa 1993.
• J. Parry, European Citizenship, London 1991, s. 20.
• P. Biernig, The Danish Proposal to the Intergovernmental Conference on Political Union, [w:] The European Ombudsman. Origins, Establishment, Evolution, s. 43-44.
• M. Grzybowski, Konstytucja Królestwa Danii, Warszawa 2002.
• E. Holm, The Ombudsman - A Gift from Scandinavia to the World, [w:] The Danish Ombudsman, Copenhagen 1995, s. 14.
• J. Andersen, The Danish Ombudsman, [w:] The European Ombudsman. Origins, Establishment, Evolution, s. 29.
• K. Revsbech, The Growth of Danish Administrative Law, [w:] Danish Law in European Perspective, pod red. B. Dahl, T. Melchior, L. A. Rehot, D. Tamm, Copenhagen 1996, s. 159-160;
• H. Gammeltoft-Hansen, J. Andersen, K. Larsen, K. Loiborg, Forvaltningsret, Copenhagen 1994, s. 562.
• R. Davis, Quasi-judicial Review: The European Ombudsman as an Alternative to the European Courts, "Web Journal of Current Legal Issues" 2000, vol. 1.
• M. Anderson, N. der Boer, G. Miller, European citizenship and cooperation in justice and home affairs, [w:] A. Duff, J. Pinder, Maastricht and Beyond, London 1994, s. 111;
• M. J. Baun, An Imperfect Union: The Maastricht Treaty and the New Politics of European Integration, Oxford 1996, s. 79-101.
• J. Closs, G. Reinesch, D. Vignes, J. Weyland, Le Traité de Maastricht. Genèse, analyse, commentaire, Brussels 1994, s. 401-403.
• E. A. Marias, The Right to petition to the European Parliament after Maastricht, "European Law Review", vol. 19, 1994, s. 169-181.
• E. A. Marias, Le droit de pétition devant le Parlement européen [w:] red. E. A. Marias, European Citizenship, Maastricht 1994, s. 81-101.
• E. Popławska, Ombudsman Unii Europejskiej, "Przegląd Legislacyjny" [Warszawa] 1998, nr 1-2, s. 269;
• Z. Hummer, Stellung und Funktion des Burgerbeauftragten des Europaischen Parlaments, Innsbruck 1995.
• P. Bonnor, The European Ombudsman: a novel source of soft law in the European Union, "European Law Review" 2000, vol. 25, s. 40.
• E. A. Marias, Mechanism of Protection of Union Citizen's Rights [w:] A Citizen's Europe. In search of a New Order, red. A. Rosas, E. Antol, London 1995, s. 216.

Identyfikatory

DOI

10.17951/sil.2014.22.0.603