Constitutional Tribunal in an Argument with the President, Government and Parliament of the Polish Republic in 2015

• Autorzy: Grzegorz Górski , Joanna Górska-Szymczak
• Języki publikacji: EN

Abstrakty

EN

The judicial decision of the Constitutional Tribunal from 3rd December 2015 (K/34/15) is the subject of the analysis. In this case the Tribunal considered the matter of the constitutional character of the act on the Constitutional Tribunal from June 2015. The authors focused on the question of justification of the Tribunal opinion regarding the regulations which were the basis for the appointment of five judges of the Constitutional Tribunal by the Sejm of VII term. While discussing the justification of the Tribunal the authors emphasize that the Tribunal justified its opinion, according to which it acknowledged the constitutional basis for the appointment of three individuals and questioned the constitutional character of the same regulations in case of two others, in an entirely superficial manner. The authors present as a significant element of their reasoning the circumstances of adopting by the American Supreme Court in 1803 the adjudication in the Marbury v. Madison case in order to emphasize in this context the weight of rational and thorough argumentation of the grave constitutional matters. Taking the above into account, it is even more clearly visible that in the discussed judicial decision the Constitutional Tribunal limited its reaction to the laconic set of arguments regarding this key matter. (original abstract)

Słowa kluczowe

EN

Constitutional Court; President; Parliament

PL

Trybunał Konstytucyjny; Prezydent; Parlament

• Czasopismo: Law and Administration in Post-Soviet Europe
• Rocznik: 2019
• Numer: vol. 6, iss. 1
• Strony: 46--58

Twórcy

autor

Grzegorz Górski

• Kolegium Jagiellońskie - Toruńska Szkoła Wyższa

autor

Joanna Górska-Szymczak

• Kolegium Jagiellońskie - Toruńska Szkoła Wyższa

Bibliografia

• Banaszak B., Gloss to the Judicial Decision of the Constitutional Tribunal from 3rd December 2015, Przegląd Sejmowy Nr 2(133)/2016.
• Banaszak B., Opinion from 24th November 2015, BAS-69/15A.
• Górski G., Supreme Court of the United States by 1930, Lublin 2006.
• Górski G., The case Marbury v. Madison from 1803 r. and the Shaping of the Constitutional Judicature Rules, Czasopismo Prawno-Historyczne, Poznań 2000, Vol. LI.
• Mojak R., Model of Presidency in the Constitution of Polish Republic from 2nd April 1997 [in:] System of Government in the Republic of Poland. The Constitutional Premises and the System Practice,ed. M. Grzybowski, Warszawa 2006.
• Mojak R., Parliament and Government in the System of the Third Republic of Poland, Lublin 2007.
• Muszyński M., Anatomy of "a plot". Legal Analysis of the Process of Appointing the Constitutional Tribunal Judges in the Autumn 2015 Przegląd Sejmowy Nr 2(139)/2017.
• Sarnecki P., Comments to selected regulations of the Constitution of Polish Republic [in:] The President of Polish Republic. The Comment, Kraków 2000.
• Szymanek J., Opinion from 23rd November 2015, BAS-69/15A.
• Wiącek M., Gloss to the Judgement of Constitutional Tribunal from 3rd December 2015, Przegląd Sejmowy Nr 2(133)/2016.
• Winczorek P., Comments to the Constitution of Polish Republic from 2nd April 1997, Warszawa 2000.
• Zaremba P., History of the United States, London 1968.

Identyfikatory

DOI

10.2478/lape-2019-0005