Effects of International Customary Law in the Legal Order of the European Union

• Autorzy: Dagmara Kornobis-Romanowska
• Języki publikacji: EN

Abstrakty

EN

The customary provisions in EU law formally may take effect and be enforced within the domestic legal orders of the Member States and internal law of the international organizations. However, the substantive question is if and how the customary international law (in force) may be capable of creating individual rights (direct applicability) with a direct effect in national and EU courts. Also an informal relationship may be observed, when the international law and EU law share the same values and may influence each other. In consideration of the foregoing, the objective of this paper is to analyse the status of the rules in question within the legal regime of the EU (formal perspective), and especially their judicial application in the conditions of complexity and imprecision (substantive perspective), but the essential purpose is to analyse the final legal effect given within the EU regime to the international customary law.(original abstract)

Słowa kluczowe

EN

Law; International law; European Community law

PL

Prawo; Prawo międzynarodowe; Prawo WE

• Czasopismo: Wroclaw Review of Law, Administration & Economics
• Rocznik: 2018
• Tom: 8
• Numer: nr 2
• Strony: 405--428

Twórcy

autor

Dagmara Kornobis-Romanowska

• University of Wroclaw

Bibliografia

• Bebr G., 'Agreements Concluded by the Community and their Possible Direct Effect: From International Fruit Company to Kupferberg' (1983) 20 CMLRev 35.
• Bleckmann A., 'Die Position des Volkerrechts im inneren Rechtsraum der Europaischen Gemeinschaften. Monismus oder Dualismus der Rechtsordnungen?' (1975) Jahrbuch fur Internationales Recht 300.
• Cremona M., 'External Relations of the EU and the Member States: Competence, Mixed Agreements, International Responsibility, and Effects of International Law' in X. Xenopoulos (ed), External Relations of the EU and the Member State (FIDE 2006 National Reports) (2006) 319.
• Czapliński W., 'Glosa do wyroku TS z dn. 3 września 2008r., C- 402/05 i C-415/05' (2010) 4 Europejski Przegąd Sądowy (EPS) 38.
• Czuczai J., 'The Autonomy of the EU Legal Order and the Law-making Activities of International Organizations, Some Examples Regarding the Council's most Recent Practice' (2012) 31 Yearbook of European Law 452.
• Dashwood A., 'Preliminary Rulings on the Interpretation of Mixed Agreements' in D. O'Keeffe, A. Bavaso (eds), Liber Amicorum in Honour of Lord Slynn (2000).
• de Burca G., 'The European Court of Justice and the International Legal Order after Kadi' (2009) 51 Harvard International Law Journal 1.
• Eckes C., 'International Law as the Law of the EU: the Role of the ECJ' in E. Cannizzaro, P. Palchetti, R.A. Wessel (eds), International Law as the Law of the European Union (2011).
• Eckes Ch., 'International law as law of the EU: the role of the European Court of Justice" (2010) 6 Cleer Working Papers, Centre for Law of EU External Relations.
• Elias O., 'General International law in the European Court of Justice: from hypothesis to reality?' (2000) 31 Netherlands Yearbook of International Law 3.
• Etienne J., 'Loyalty Towards International Law as a Constitutional Principle of European Union Law?' (2010)2 Jean Monnet Working Paper.
• Evans M.D., Koutrakos P. (eds), The International Responsibility of the European Union: European and International Perspectives (2013).
• Gaja G., 'Trends in Judicial Activism and Judicial Self-Restraint Relating to Community Agreements' in E. Cannizzaro (ed.), The European Union as an Actor in International Relations (2002) 117.
• Ganshof van der Meersch W., 'L'ordre juridique des Communautes europeennes et le droit international' (1975) 148 Receil des Cours 1.
• Guzman A., 'The Design of International Agreements' (2005) 16 European Journal of International Law 579.
• Hartley T., 'International Agreements and the Community Legal System: Some Recent Developments', (1983) 8 European Law Review 383.
• Jacobs F.G., 'The Internal Legal Effects of the EU's International Agreements and the Protection of Individual Rights', in A. Arnull et al (eds), A Constitutional Order of States (2011) 529.
• Jacobs F.G., Roberts S., The Effect of Treaties in Domestic Law (1987).
• Kaczorowska A., European Union Law (3rd ed 2013).
• Kokott J., Sobotta Ch., 'The Kadi Case - Constitutional Core Values and International Law - Finding the Balance?' (2012) 23(4) The European Journal of International Law 1024.
• Konstadinides T., 'When in Europe: Customary International Law and EU Competence in the Sphere of External Action' (2011) 13 German Law Journal 1177.
• Korenica F., The EU Accession to the ECHR, Between Luxembourg's Search for Autonomy and Strasbourg's Credibility on Human Rights Protection (2015) 54.
• Kuijper P.J., 'Customary International Law, decisions of International Organizations and Other Techniques for Ensuring Respect for International Legal Rules in European Community Law' in J. Wouters, A., Nollkaemper, E.De Wet (eds), The Europeisation of International Law (2008) 29.
• Kuijper P.J., 'From Dyestuffs to Kosovo Wine: From Avoidance to Acceptance by the European Community Courts of Customary International Law as a Limit to Community Action' in I.F. Dekker, H.H.G. Post (eds), On the foundation and sources of public international law On the Foundations and Sources of International Law (2003) 151.
• Kuijper P.J., '"It Shall Contribute to.the Strict Observance and development of International Law." The Role of the Court of Justice' in A. Rosas, E. Levits, Y. Bot (eds), The Court of Justice and Construction of Europe: Analyses and perspectives on Sixty Years of Case-law (2013) 589.
• Kuijper P.J., 'The Case Law of the Court of Justice of the EU and the Allocation of External Relations Powers: Whither the Traditional Role of the Executive in the EU Foreign Relations?' in M. Cremona, A. Thies, The European Court of Justice and the External Relations Law: Constitutional Challenges (2014) 105.
• Lauterpacht H., International Bill of Rights of Man (1945).
• Lauterpacht H., The Function of Law in International Community (2011).
• Lenaerts K., 'Direct applicability and direct effect of International Law in the EU legal order' in I. Govaere, E. Lannon, P. Van Elsuwege, S. Adam (eds), The European Union in the World, Essays in Honour of Marc Maresceau (2014) 60.
• Lenaerts K., 'Droit international et monisme de l'ordre juridique de l'Union' (2010) Revue de la Faculte de droit de l'Universite de Liege 505.
• Martines F., 'Direct Effect of International Agreements of the European Union' (2014) 25 European Journal of International Law 144.
• McGinnis J.O., 'The Comparative Disadvantage of Customary International Law' (2006) 30 Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 9.
• Megzari A., The Internal Justice of the United Nations: A Critical History 1945-2015 (2015) 431.
• Meessen K.M., 'The application of rules of public international law within Community law' (1976) 13 CMLRev 485.
• Murphy S.D., The Identification of Customary International Law and Other Topics: The Sixty-Seventh Session of the International Law Commission (2015).
• Neff S.C., 'In Search of Clarity: Non Liquet and International Law' in K.H. Kaikobad, M. Bohlander (eds), International Law and Power: Perspectives on Legal Order and Justice - Essays in Honour of Colin Warbrick (2009) 63.
• Orakhelashvili A., 'Commentary to the art. 30 Convention of 1986' in O. Corten, P. Klein, 1 The Vienna Conventions on the Law of the Treaties: a commentary (2011) 802.
• Ott A., 'Thirty years of case-law by the European Court of Justice on international law: a pragmatic approach towards its integration' in V. Kronenberger (ed), The EU and the International Legal Order: Discord or Harmony (2001) 95.
• Peters A., 'The Position of International Law Within the European Community Legal Order' (1997) 40 German Yearbook of International Law 9.
• Rosas A., 'The Future of Mixity, in Mixed Agreements Revisited: the EU and its Member States in the World', in Ch. Hilion, P. Koutrakos, Mixed Agreements Revisited: The EU and its Member States (2010) 367.
• Rosas A., 'With a Little Help from My Friends: International Case- Law as a Source of Reference for the EU Courts' (2005) 1 The Global Community - Yearbook of International Law and Jurisprudence 217.
• Rossen J.W. van, 'Interaction between EU Law and International Law in the light of Intertanko and Kadi: the dilemma of norms binding the Member States but not the Community' (2009) 4 CLEER Working Papers.
• Schermers H.G., 'Community law and international law' (1975) 12 CMLRev 77
• Simon D., 'La panacee de l'interpretation conforme: injection homeopathique ou therapie palliative?' in De Rome a Lisbonne: les juridictions de l'Union europeenne a la croisee des chemins, Melanges en l'honneur de P Mengozzi (2013) 279.
• Timmermans C., 'The EU and the Public International Law' (1999) 4 European Foreign Affairs Review 181.
• Uerpmann-Wittzack R., 'The Constitutional Role of International Law' in A. von Bogdandy, J. Bast (eds.), Principles of European Constitutional Law (2nd ed. 2010) 138.
• Van Panhuys H.F., 'Conflicts between the Law of the European Communities and Other Rules of International Law'(1965-66) 3 Common Market Law Review (CMLRev) 420.
• Van Rossem J.W., 'The Autonomy of the EU law: More is Less?' in RA Wessel, S. Blokmans (eds.), Between Autonomy and Dependence: The EU Legal Order under the Influence of International Organizations (2013) 1.
• Wessel R.A., 'Reconsidering the Relationship between International and EU Law: Towards a Content-Based Approach?' in E. Cannizzaro, P. Palchetti, R.A. Wessel (eds.), International Law as Law of the European Union (2011).
• Wolfke K., Custom in Present International Law (2nd ed 1993).
• Wolfke K., Rozwój i kodyfikacja prawa międzynarodowego, Wybrane zagadnienia z praktyki ONZ (1972).

Identyfikatory

DOI

https://doi.org/10.1515/wrlae-2018-0056