Russia: A 'Hidden' Migration Transition and a Winding Road towards a Mature Immigration Country?

• Autorzy: Zuzanna Brunarska , Mikhail Denisenko
• Języki publikacji: EN

Abstrakty

EN

The article offers a new perspective on contemporary and past migration processes in the post-Soviet area by testing the usefulness of the concept of a migration cycle for the Russian case. By adopting the longue durée approach, we attempt to assess the advancement of Russia's migration cycle, arguing at the same time that it constitutes an interesting, yet not an obvious case with which to test the utility of the concept. We postulate that, in tracking Russia's migration trajectories in pre-1991 times, it is important to account for both the flows between Russia as the-then state entity (i.e. the Tsarist Empire, later the Soviet Union) and foreign countries and the flows between Russia as the core of the empire and its eastern and southern peripheries. Our analyses show that while - taking into account statistical considerations - Russia has undoubtedly already undergone the migration transition, it has not yet reached the stage of a mature immigration country. We also contend that migration transition for Russia occurred internally - within the-then state borders - and revealed itself with its transformation from a Soviet republic into a federative state. (original abstract)

Słowa kluczowe

EN

Population migration; Sociology of migration; Evaluation of the transformation process

PL

Migracja ludności; Socjologia migracji; Ocena procesu transformacji

• Czasopismo: Central and Eastern European Migration Review
• Rocznik: 2021
• Tom: 10
• Numer: nr 1
• Strony: 143--172

Twórcy

autor

Zuzanna Brunarska

• Centre of Migration Research, University of Warsaw, Poland

autor

Mikhail Denisenko

• National Research University Higher School of Economics, Moscow, Russia

Bibliografia

• Abashin S., Dmitriy A., Bekmakhanova N. (eds) (2008). Tsentral'naya Aziya v sostave Rossiyskoy Imperii. Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie.
• Abylkhozhin Z., Kozybaev M., Tatimov M. (1989). Iz istorii narodov SSSR. Kazakhstanskaya tragediya. Voprosy istorii 7: 53-71.
• Akerman S. (1976). Theories and Methods of Migration Research, in: H. Runblom, H. Norman (eds), From Sweden to America: A History of Migration, pp. 19-75. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.
• Andreev E., Darskiy L., Khar'kova T. (1998). Demograficheskaya istoriya Rossii: 1927-1959. Moscow: Informatika.
• Arango J. (2012). Early Starters and Latecomers. Comparing Countries of Immigration and Immigration Regimes in Europe, in: M. Okólski (ed.), European Immigrations. Trends, Structures and Policy Implications, pp. 45-64. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
• Brunarska Z. (2013). Współczesne migracje na obszarze poradzieckim przez pryzmat koncepcji migracji poimperialnych. Central and Eastern European Migration Review 2(2): 39-54.
• Brunarska Z., Nestorowicz J., Markowski S. (2014). Intra- vs. Extra-Regional Migration in the Post-Soviet Space. Eurasian Geography and Economics 55(3): 133-155.
• BVA (2020). Spätaussiedler und ihre Angehörigen. Zeitreihe 1950-2019. Bundesverwaltungsamt. Der zentrale Dienstleister des Bundes. Online: https://www.bva.bund.de/SharedDocs/Downloads/DE/Buerger/Migration-Integr... (accessed: 23 April 2021).
• Chesnais J.-C. (1986). La transition démographique: étapes, formes, implications économiques. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France.
• Chudinovskikh O., Denisenko M. (2020). Labour Migration on the Post-Soviet Territory, in: M. Denisenko, S. Strozza, M. Light (eds), Migration from the Newly Independent States 25 Years After the Collapse of the USSR, pp. 55-80. Cham: Springer.
• Codagnone C. (1998). The New Migration in Russia in the 1990s, in: K. Koser, H. Lutz (eds), The New Migration in Europe. Social Constructions and Social Realities, pp. 39-59. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
• Dameshek L., Remnev A. (eds) (2007). Sibir' v sostave Rossiyskoy Imperii. Moscow: Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie.
• Dassetto F. (1990). Pour une theorie des cycles migratoires, in: A. Bastenier, F. Dassetto (eds), Immigration et nouveaux pluralisms: une confrontation de societes, pp. 11-40. Brussels: De Boeck-Wesmael.
• Davis J. (1922). The Russian Immigrant. New York: Macmillan.
• De Haas H. (2010). Migration Transitions: A Theoretical and Empirical Inquiry into the Developmental Drivers of International Migration. International Migration Institute Working Papers 24. Oxford: University of Oxford, International Migration Institute.
• Denisenko M. (2013). Istoricheskie i aktual'nye tendentsii emigratsii iz Rossii, in: I. Ivanov (ed.), Migratsiya v Rossii: 2000-2012. Khrestomatiya v 3 tomakh. I, 2, pp. 495-503. Moscow: Spetskniga.
• Denisenko M., Strozza S., Light M. (eds) (2020). Migration from the Newly Independent States. 25 Years After the Collapse of the USSR. Cham: Springer.
• EMISS (2021). Edinaya mezhvedomstvennaya informatsionno-statisticheskaya sistema. Online: https://www.fedstat.ru/ (accessed: 10 January 2021).
• European Social Survey Cumulative File, ESS 1-9 (2020). Data file edition 1.0. NSD - Norwegian Centre for Research Data, Norway - Data Archive and distributor of ESS data for ESS ERIC. doi:10.21338/NSD-ESS-CUMULATIVE.
• Fassman H. (2009). Von jungen und alten Einwanderungsländern: die Geographie der europäischen Migration. Mitteilungen der Österreichischen Geographischen Gesellschaft 151: 9-32.
• Fassmann H., Reeger U. (2008). 'Old' Immigration Countries. Synthesis Report. Vienna: IDEA Working Papers 3.
• Fassmann H., Reeger U. (2012). 'Old' Immigration Countries in Europe. The Concept and Empirical Examples, in: M. Okólski (ed.), European Immigrations: Trends, Structures and Policy Implications, pp. 67-92. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
• Fassmann H., Musil E., Gruber K. (2014). Dynamic Historical Analysis of Longer Term Migratory, Labour Market and Human Capital Processes in the SEEMIG Region. SEEMIG Working Papers 3. Budapest: Hungarian Demographic Research Institute.
• Fielding A. (1993). Mass Migration and Economic Restructuring, in: R. Kind (ed.), Mass Migrations in Europe: The Legacy and the Future, pp. 7-17. London: Belhaven Press.
• Fields G. (1994). The Migration Transition in Asia. Asian and Pacific Migration Journal 3(1): 7-30.
• Findlay A. M., Jones H., Davidson G. M. (1998). Migration Transition or Migration Transformation in the Asian Dragon Economies? International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 22(4): 643-663.
• Goskomstat of Russia (1998). Naselenie Rossii za 100 let (1897-1997). Statisticheskiy sbornik. Moscow: Goskomstat.
• Goskomstat SSSR (1990). Narodnoe khozyaystvo SSSR. Statisticheskiy ezhegodnik 1988, 1989, 1990. Moscow: Finansy i statistika.
• Górny A. (2017). Eastwards EU Enlargements and Migration Transition in Central and Eastern Europe. Geografie 122(4): 476-499.
• Górny A., Kaczmarczyk P. (2020). European Migration Transition in the Context of Post-Enlargement Migration from and into Central and Eastern Europe, in: C. Inglis, W. Li, B. Khadria (eds), The SAGE Handbook of International Migration, pp. 359-375. London: Sage.
• Hatton T. J., Williamson J. G. (1994). What Drove the Mass Migrations from Europe in the Late Nineteenth Century? Population and Development Review 20(3): 533-559.
• Hatton T. J., Williamson J. G. (2009). Emigration in the Long Run: Evidence from Two Global Centuries. Asian-Pacific Economic Literature 23(2): 17-28.
• Heitman S. (1987). The Third Soviet Emigration: Jewish, German, and Armenian Emigration from the USSR since World War II. Cologne: Berichte des Bundesinsituts für Ostwissenschaftliche und Internationale Studien 21.
• Heitman S. (1988). The Third Soviet Emigration. Soviet Jewish Affairs 18(2): 17-43.
• Incaltarau C., Simionov L. M. (2017). Is Eastern Europe Following the Same Transition Model as the South? A Regional Analysis of the Main Migration Transition Drivers, in: G. C. Pascariu, M. A. Pedrosa Da Silva Duarte (eds), Core-Periphery Patterns across the European Union: Case Studies and Lessons from Eastern and Southern Europe, pp. 199-232. Bingley: Emerald Publishing Limited.
• INS (1988). Statistical Yearbook of the Immigration and Naturalization Service, 1987. Washington, DC: US Immigration and Naturalization Service, US Government Printing Office.
• IOM (2002). Migration Trends in Eastern Europe and Central Asia: 2001-2002 Review. Geneva: International Organisation for Migration.
• Iontsev V. (2014). Emigratsiya naseleniya iz Rossii (Istoricheskie aspekty), in: V. Lokosov, L. Rybakovskiy (eds), Migratsionnye protsessy v Rossii, pp. 51-66. Moscow: Ekon-inform.
• Iontsev V., Ivakhniouk I. (2002). Russia in the World Migration Flows: Trends of the Last Decade (1992-2001), in: V. Iontsev (ed.), World in the Mirror of International Migration, pp. 34-87. International Migration of Population: Russia and the Contemporary World 10. Moscow: MAX Press.
• Kabuzan V. (1996). Russkie v mire. St Petersburg: Russian Baltic Information Center 'BLITZ' Publishing House.
• Karakhanov M. (1983). Nekapitalicheskiy put' razvitiya i problemy narodonaseleniya. Tashkent: Fan.
• Kas'yanenko V. (1972). Zavoevanie ekonomicheskoy nezavisimosti SSSR (1917-1940 gg.). Moscow: Politizdat.
• Khorev B., Moiseenko V. (eds) (1974). Migratsionnaya podvizhnost' naseleniya v SSSR. Moscow: Statistika.
• Krasinets E., Kubishin E., Tyuryukanova E. (2000). Nelegal'naya migratsiya v Rossiyu. Moscow: Academia.
• Kreindler I. (1986). The Soviet Deported Nationalities: A Summary and an Update. Soviet Studies 38(3): 387-405.
• Laruelle M. (2010). The Ideological Shift on the Russian Radical Right. Problems of Post-Communism 57(6): 19-31.
• Levada-Center (2020). Ksenofobiya i natsionalizm. Online: https://www.levada.ru/2020/09/23/ksenofobiya-i-natsionalizm-2/ (accessed: 20 January 2021).
• Lohr E. (2012). Russian Citizenship. From Empire to Soviet Union. Cambridge, MA, London: Harvard University Press.
• Lyubavskiy M. (1996). Obzor istorii russkoy kolonizatsii s drevneyshikh vremen i do XX veka. Moscow: Moscow State University Publishing.
• Markowitz L. P., Peshkova V. (2016). Anti-Immigrant Mobilization in Russia's Regions: Local Movements and Framing Processes. Post-Soviet Affairs 32(3): 272-298.
• MDM (2021). Statisticheskie svedeniya po migratsionnoy situatsii. Main Directorate for Migration, Ministry of Internal Affairs. Online: https://xn--b1aew.xn--p1ai/Deljatelnost/statistics/migracionnaya (accessed: 10 February 2021).
• Moiseenko V. (2013). Issledovaniya migratsii v istoricheskoy perspektive, in: I. Ivanov (ed.), Migratsiya v Rossii: 2000-2012. Khrestomatiya v 3 tomakh, I, 3, pp. 563-580. Moscow: Spetskniga.
• Moiseenko V. (2015). Krest'yanskie pereseleniya v 1920-e gody (Iz istorii migratsii v Rossii). Demograficheskoe obozrenie 2(3): 87-141.
• Moiseenko V. (2017). Mezhdunarodnaya migratsiya v Rossii (SSSR) v kontse XIX-pervoy treti XX veka. Chast' tret'ya. Mezhdunarodnaya migratsiya v SSSR v 1923-1930 gg. Demograficheskoe Obozrenie 4(2): 109-132.
• Moiseenko V. (2019). Ot poddanstva Rossii k grazhdanstvu SSSR. Trudy Instituta Gosudarstva i Prava RAN 14(6): 58-94.
• Monitoring ksenofobskikh nastroeniy, iyul' 2018 goda. (2018). Yuri Levada Analytical Center. Online: www.levada.ru/2018/08/27/monitoring-ksenofobskih-nastroenij/ (accessed 17 December 2020).
• Obolenskiy-Osinskiy V. (1928). Mezhdunarodnye i mezhkontinental'nye migratsii v dovoennoy Rossii i SSSR. Moscow: TsSU SSSSR.
• Okólski M. (ed.) (2012a). European Immigrations: Trends, Structures and Policy Implications. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
• Okólski M. (2012b). Introduction, in: M. Okólski (ed.), European Immigrations: Trends, Structures and Policy Implications, pp. 7-22. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
• Okólski M. (2012c). Transition from Emigration to Immigration. Is It the Destiny of Modern European Countries? in: M. Okólski (ed.), European Immigrations. Trends, Structures and Policy Implications, pp. 23-44. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
• Pang E. F. (1994). An Eclectic Approach to Turning Points in Migration. Asian and Pacific Migration Journal 3(1): 81-92.
• Platunov N. (1976). Pereselencheskaya politika sovetskogo gosudarstva i ee osushchestvlenie v SSSR (1917-iyun' 1941 gg.). Tomsk: Izdatel'stvo Tomskogo Universiteta.
• Polyan P. (2005). Emigratsiya: kto i kogda v XX v. pokidal Rossiyu, in: O. Glezer, P. Polyan (eds), Rossiya i ee regiony v XX v.: territoriya - rasselenie - migratsii, pp. 493-519. Moscow: OGI.
• Pratsinakis M., Hatziprokopiou P., King R. (2017). Beyond Migration Binaries and Linear Transitions: The Complexification of Greece's Migratory Landscape at Times of Crisis. University of Sussex Working Paper 92. Brighton: University of Sussex.
• Remnev A., Suvorova N. (2010). Upravlyaemaya kolonizatsiya i stikhiynye migratsionnye protsessy na aziatskikh okrainakh Rossiyskoy Imperii. Politiya 3-4(58-59): 150-191.
• RIA Novosti (2016). Glava FMS: v 2015 godu chislo migrantov v Rossii stabilizirovalos'. Online: https://ria.ru/20160102/1353262641.html (accessed: 18 February 2021).
• Rosstat (2019). The Demographic Yearbook of Russia 2019. Moscow: Rosstat.
• Rosstat (2021a). Informatsiya o sotsial'no-ekonomicheskom polozhenii Rossii: 2021 g. Online: https://gks.ru/bgd/free/B21_00/main.htm (accessed: 17 May 2021).
• Rosstat (2021b). Statistical Database. Online: https://rosstat.gov.ru/folder/10705 (accessed: 30 January 2021).
• Rowland R. H. (1988). Union Republic Migration Trends in the USSR during the 1980s. Soviet Geography 29(9): 809-829.
• Rybakovskiy L. (1990). Naselenie Dal'nego Vostoka za 150 let. Moscow: Nauka.
• Rybakovskiy L. (ed.) (2008). Transformatsiya migratsionnykh protsessov na postsovetskom prostranstve. Moscow: ISPR RAN.
• Schmidt J. F. (1959). When a People Migrate: Footnote to the Mennonite Migration of the 1870s. Mennonite Quarterly Review 33(2): 152-155.
• Shlapentokh V. (2007). The Hatred of Others: The Kremlin's Powerful but Risky Weapon. World Affairs 169(3): 134-142.
• Skeldon R. (2012). Migration Transitions Revisited: Their Continued Relevance for The Development of Migration Theory. Population, Space and Place 18(2): 154-166.
• Thomas B. (1954). Migration and Economic Growth: A Study of Great Britain and the Atlantic Economy. New York: Cambridge University Press.
• Tolts M. (2020). A Half Century of Jewish Emigration from the Former Soviet Union, in: M. Denisenko, S. Strozza, M. Light (eds), Migration from the Newly Independent States 25 Years After the Collapse of the USSR, pp. 323-344. Cham: Springer.
• Tudoryanu N. (1986). Ocherki rossiyskoy trudovoy emigratsii perioda imperializma (v Germaniyu, Skandinavskie Strany i SShA). Kishinev: Shtiintsa.
• Willcox W. F. (1929). Statistics of Migrations, National Tables, Russia, Italy, in: W. F. Willcox (ed.), International Migrations, Volume I: Statistics, pp. 790-840. New York: National Bureau of Economic Research.
• World Bank (2021). World Bank Open Data. Online: https://data.worldbank.org/ (accessed: 15 January 2021).
• Zayonchkovskaya Z. (1993). Vnutrennyaya i vneshnyaya migratsiya, in: A. Vishnevskiy, S. Zakharov (eds), Naselenie Rossii 1993. Ezhegodnyy demograficheskiy doklad, pp. 57-72. Moscow: Evraziya.
• Zayonchkovskaya Z. (1999). Vnutrennyaya migratsiya v Rossii i v SSSR v XX veke kak otrazhenie sotsial'noy modernizatsii. Mir Rossii 4: 22-34.
• Zayonchkovskaya Z. (2005). Migratsionnyy krizis i migratsionnyy vzryv v Rossii v 1980-e i 1990-e gody, in: P. Polyan, O. Glezer (eds), Rossiya i ee regiony v XX veke: territoriya - rasselenie - migratsii, pp. 383-412. Moscow: OGI.
• Zayonchkovskaya Z., Tyuryukanova E. (eds) (2010). Migratsiya i demograficheskiy krizis v Rossii. Moscow: MAKS Press.
• Zelinsky W. (1971). The Hypothesis of the Mobility Transition. Geographical Review 61(2): 219-249.
• Zemskov V. (1991). Rozhdenie 'vtoroy emigratsii' (1944-1952). Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya 4: 3-24.

Identyfikatory

DOI

10.17467/ceemr.2021.08