Are Economic Majors "Indoctrinated" by their Education? : Public Good Game Quasi-Experiment

• Autorzy: Joanna Dzionek-Kozlowska , Jarosław Neneman
• Języki publikacji: EN

Abstrakty

EN

Economic education is commonly blamed for negatively affecting students' values and attitudes. Students of economics are repeatedly reported to differ from other majors. The differences are commonly explained by the learning effect (the indoctrination hypothesis) and the self-selection of specific persons to economics. We aim to contribute to the nurture vs nature debate on economics students by testing the indoctrination (nurture) and the self-selection (nature) hypotheses. Working with undergraduate economics and non-economic majors (N=286), we ran a Public Good Game (PGG) quasi-experiment. To test the self-selection hypothesis, we compared levels of donation in the PGG by both subsamples. To test the indoctrination hypothesis, we (1) analysed the results of economics students at different stages of their education and (2) juxtaposed their donations in the PGG with their academic performance. If economic education affects student attitudes, those who master economic theory better should be more "indoctrinated" and, as such, less eager to donate their endowments to the common fund in the PGG. However, no difference between the results of the first-year and second-year students has been found. Also, no correlation between exam scores and students' donations in the PGG has been revealed. Nonetheless, we have detected a statistically significant difference between the economics and non-economics majors, which allows us to conclude that economics students' atypicality comes from their self-selection of economic studies and is not attributable to economic teaching. (original abstract)

Słowa kluczowe

EN

Economic education; Social norms; Common good

PL

Edukacja ekonomiczna; Normy społeczne; Dobro wspólne

• Czasopismo: Economics & Sociology
• Rocznik: 2022
• Tom: 15
• Numer: nr 2
• Strony: 110--124

Twórcy

autor

Joanna Dzionek-Kozlowska

• University of Lodz, Poland

autor

Jarosław Neneman

• University of Lodz, Poland

Bibliografia

• Ahmed, A. (2008). Can education affect pro-social behavior? International Journal of Social Economics, 35(4), 298-307. https://doi.org/10.1108/03068290810854565
• Altenmeyer-Bartscher, M., Bershadskyy, D. & Schreck, P. & Timme, F. (2017). Endogenous institution formation in public good games: The effect of economic education. IWH Discussion Papers, No. 29/2017.
• van den Assem, M. J., van Dolder, D. & Thaler, R. H. (2012). Split of steal? Cooperative behavior when the stakes are large. Management Science, 58(1), 2-20. https://doi.org/10.1287/mnsc.1110.1413
• Bauman, Y. & Rose, E. (2011). Selection or indoctrination: Why do economics students donate less than the rest? Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 79(3), 318-327. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jebo.2011.02.010
• Boylan, M. (2015). Learning economics: A cautionary tale. Sociological Forum, 30(1), 234-239. https://doi.org/10.1111/socf.12154
• Cadsby, C. B. & Maynes, E. (1998). Choosing between a socially efficient and free-riding equilibrium: Nurses versus economics and business students. Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 37(2), 183-192.
• Carter, J. R., & Irons, M. D. (1991). Are economists different, and if so, why? Journal of Economic Perspectives, 5(2), 171-177.
• Cipriani, G. P., Lubian, D. & Zago, A. (2009). Natural born economists? Journal of Economic Psychology, 30(3), 455-468. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.joep.2008.10.001
• Dasgupta, U. & Menon, A. (2011). Trust and trustworthiness among Economics Majors. Economics Bulletin, 31(4), 2799-2815.
• Delgado, C., Venkatesh, M., Branco, M. C. & Silva T. (2020). Ethics, responsibility and sustainability orientation among economics and management masters' students. International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, 21(2), 181-199.
• Dawson, G. G. (1966). Changing Students' Attitudes. Improving College and University Teaching, 14(3), 200-203. https://doi.org/10.1080/00193089.1966.10532546
• Dzionek-Kozlowska, J. & Neneman, J. (2021). Educated or Indoctrinated? Remarks on the Influence of Economic Teaching on Students' Attitudes Based on Evidence from the Public Good Game Experiment. Studies in Logic, Grammar and Rhetoric, 66(79), 353-371. https://doi.org/10.2478/slgr-2021-0020
• Dzionek-Kozlowska, J. & Rehman, S. N. (2017). Attitudes of economics and sociology students towards cooperation: A cross-cultural study. Economics & Sociology, 10(4), 124-136. https://doi.org/10.14254/2071-789X.2017/10-4/10
• Dzionek-Kozlowska, J. & Rehman, S. N. (2017). Indoctrination, preselection or culture? Economic education and attitudes towards cooperation. Gospodarka Narodowa. The Polish Journal of Economics, 292(6), 57-77. https://doi.org/10.33119/GN/100739
• Dzionek-Kozlowska, J. & Rehman, S. N. (2019). Career Choices and Moral Choices. Changing Tracks in the Trolley Problem. Studies in Logic, Grammar and Rhetoric, 59(72), 177-189. https://doi.org/10.2478/slgr-2019-0036
• Etzioni, A. (2015). The moral effects of economic teaching. Sociological Forum, 30(1), 288-233.
• Frank, R. H., Gilovich, T. & Regan, D. T. (1993). Does studying economics inhibit cooperation? Journal of Economic Perspectives, 7(2), 159-171.
• Frank, B. & Schulze, G. G. (2000). Does economics make citizens corrupt? Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization, 43(1), 101-113.
• Gandal, N., Roccas, S., Sagiv, L. & Wrzesniewski, A. (2005). Personal value priorities of economists. Human Relations, 58(10), 1227-1252.
• Gerlach, P. (2017). The games economists play: Why economics students behave more selfishly than other students. PLoS ONE, 12(9), e0183814. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0183814
• Ghoshal, S. (2005). Bad management theories are destroying good management practices. Academy of Management Learning and Education, 4(1), 75-91.
• Goossens, A. & Méon, P.-G. (2015). The belief that market transactions are mutually beneficial: A comparison of the views of students in economics and other disciplines. Journal of Economic Education, 46(2), 121-134. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220485.2014.991482
• Haucap, J. & Müller, A. (2014). Why are economists so different? Nature, nurture, and gender effects in a simple trust game. Dusseldorf Institute for Competition Economics Discussion Paper No. 136.
• Henrich, J., Boyd, R., Bowles, S., Camerer, C., Fehr, E., Gintis, H., McElreath, R., Alvard, M., Barr, A., Ensminger, J., Smith-Henrich, N., Hill, K., Gil-White, F., Gurven, M., Marlowe, F. W., Patton, J. Q. & Tracer, D. (2005). "Economic man" in cross-cultural perspective: Behavioral experiments in 15 small-scale societies. Behavioral and Brain Sciences, 28(6), 795-815.
• Henrich, J. (2020). The WEIRDest people in the world. How the West become psychologically peculiar and particularly prosperous. Allen Lane (Penguin books).
• Hofstede, G., Hofstede, G. J., & Minkov, M. (2010). Cultures and Organisations: Software of the Mind (3rd Edition). New York: McGraw-Hill.
• Hummel, K., Pfaff, D. & Rost, K. (2018). Does economics and business education wash away moral judgement competence? Journal of Business Ethics, 150, 559-577. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-016-3142-6
• Ifcher, J. & Zarghamee, H. (2018). The rapid evolution of homo economicus: Brief exposure to neoclassical assumptions increases self-interested behavior. Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics, 75, 55-65. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.socec.2018.04.012
• Iida, Y. & Oda, S. H. (2011). Does economics education make bad citizens? The effect of economics education in Japan. Journal of Education for Business, 86, 234-239.
• James, T., Soroka, L. & Benjafield, J. G. (2001). Are economists rational, or just different? Social Behavior and Personality, 29(4), 359-364.
• Kaiser, J. P., Pedersen, K. S. & Koch, A. K. (2018). Do economists punish less? Games, 9(4). https://doi.org/10.3390/g9040075
• Kahneman, D., Knetsch, J. L. & Thaler, R. H. (1986). Fairness and the assumptions of economics. Journal of Business, 59(4), S285-S300.
• Krick, A., Tresp, S., Vatter, M., Ludwig, A., Wihlenda, M. & Rettenberger, M. (2016). The relationships between the Dark Triad, the Moral Judgment Level, and the Students' disciplinary choice self-selection, indoctrination, or both? Journal of Individual Differences, 37(1), 24-30.
• Laband, D. N. & Beil, R. O. (1999). Are economists more selfish than other 'social' scientists? Public Choice, 100, 85-101.
• Lanteri, A. & Rizzello, S. (2007). Ought (only) economists to defect? Stereotypes, identity, and the prisoner dilemma. Quaderni SEMeQ 21/2007.
• Lloyd, J. W. (1970). Role Playing, Collective Bargaining, and the Measurement of Attitude Change. Journal of Economic Education, 1(2), 104-110.
• Marwell, G. & Ames, R. E. (1981). Economists free ride, does anyone else? Experiments on the provision of public goods, IV. Journal of Public Economics, 15(3), 295-310.
• Mertins, V. & Warning, S. (2014). Greedy and selfish? Differences in fairness preferences of prospective lawyers and managers. Zeitschrift für Personalforschung, 28(4), 410-431.
• Neubaum, D. O., Pagell, M., Drexler, J. A., McKee-Ryan, F. M. & Larson, E. (2009). Business education and its relationship to student personal moral philosophies and attitudes toward profits: An empirical response to critics. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 8(1), 9-24.
• Ng, Y.-K. (1988). Economic efficiency versus egalitarian rights. Kyklos, 41(2), 215-237.
• O'Clock, P. & Okleshen, M. (1993). A comparison of ethical perception of business and engineering majors. Journal of Business Ethics, 12, 677-687.
• Rosengart, T., Hirsch, B. & Nitzl, C. (2020). Self-selection and socialisation effects of business and legal studies. Journal of Business Economics, 90, 1127-1145. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11573-020-00973-3
• Sally, D. (1995). Conversation and cooperation in social dilemmas: A meta-analysis of experiments from 1958 to 1992. Rationality and Society, 7, 58-92.
• Scott, J. H., & Rothman, M. P. (1975). The effect of an introductory economics course on student political attitudes. Journal of Economic Education, 6(2), 107-112.
• Seguino, S., Stevens, T. & Lutz, M. (1996). Gender and cooperative behavior: Economic Man rides alone. Feminist Economics, 2(1), 1-21.
• Spiegelman, E. (2020). Embracing the dark side? Testing the socialisation of a maximizing mindset. Economic Inquiry, 59(2), 740-761. http://dx.doi.org/10.1111/ecin.12958
• Statistics Poland (2015). National, ethnical, linguistic and religious structure of Poland. Warsaw: Statistics Poland. https://stat.gov.pl/spisy-powszechne/nsp-2011/nsp-2011-wyniki/struktura-narodowo-etniczna-jezykowa-i-wyznaniowa-ludnosci-polski-nsp-2011,22,1.html
• Thompson, F. A. (1973). The Interaction of Cognition and Affect: The Issue of Free Trade. Journal of Economic Education, 4(2), 111-115.
• Tse, A. C. B., & Au, A. K. M. (1997). Are New Zealand business students more unethical than non-business students? Journal of Business Ethics, 16, 445-450.
• Wang, L., Malhotra, D. & Murnighan, J. K. (2011). Economic education and greed. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 10(4), 643-660. http://dx.doi.org/10.5465/amle.2009.0185
• Whaples, R. (1995). Changes in attitudes among college economics students about the fairness of the market. Journal of Economic Education, 26(4), 308-313.
• World Values Survey (1981-2020). https://www.worldvaluessurvey.org/WVSOnline.jsp
• Yezer, A. M., Goldfarb, R. S. & Poppen, P. J. (1996). Does studying economics discourage cooperation? Watch what we do, not what we way or how we play. Journal of Economic Perspectives, 10(1), 177-186.

Identyfikatory

DOI

10.14254/2071-789X.2022/15-2/7