A Set of Meta-Systemetic Assumptions for Dovetailing Jaina Logic Into Jaina Metaphysics

• Autorzy: Tushar K. Sarkar
• Języki publikacji: EN

Abstrakty

EN

This paper presents an integralist approach to Jaina logic. This is built around an analysis of the pivotal notion of antarvyāpti in Jaina logic. It is shown in this connection why antarvyāpti needs to be considered the 'Core Perspective/Problem' of Jaina logic. Next, it is shown how all the salient features of Jaina logic (as viewed from its language-oriented perspective and the epistemic perspective respectively) stand intimately related to the so-called core perspective. In the remaining sections of the paper topics like relationship of the core perspective i) to various non-standard systems of logic [DL, FL, NMR etc.,], ii) to the four pillars and to the eight MPC's of Jaina philosophy, iii) to some bluntly unimaginative ways of looking at Jaina logic [e.g., Ducko- Rabbitism], iv) to the scheme of classification of propositions in Jaina logic, v) to the resulting conceptual economies related to methodology, and especially to a unified theory of Hetvābhāsa and, finally, vi) to a re-assessment of Frege-Husserl discord in the light of the significance of Jñānātmakatā vs Vākyātmakatā in Jaina logic, etc., have been discussed. Keywords: antarvyāpti, anumāpakas, anyathā-anupapanna, avinābhāva, bahirvyāpti, bhūyodarśana, DKM, Ducko-Rabbitism, epistemic view of logic, fallacious validity, Hetvābhāsa, jñānātmaka, ontic view of logic, śabdātmaka, semantic-conceptual linkage, syllogism-ism, synonymy, synthetic a-priori, vākyātmaka.(original abstract)

Słowa kluczowe

EN

Logic; Metaphysics; Logistics

PL

Logika; Metafizyka; Logistyka

• Czasopismo: Studia Humana
• Rocznik: 2023
• Tom: 12(1-2)
• Strony: 101--121

Twórcy

autor

Tushar K. Sarkar

Bibliografia

• Acārāṅga Sūtra [A Jaina Canonical Text].
• Bhatt, S. R. (ed). Papers Presented at the First International Conference on Buddhism, New Delhi: ICPR, 1984.
• Brahma, S. Some Problems of Jaina Logic and Ontology, Unpublished Ph. D. Thesis, Kolkata: Jadavpur University, 1998.
• Corcoran, J. The Founding of Logic. Modern Interpretations of Aristotle's Logic, Ancient Philosophy 14, 1994, pp. 9-24.
• Genesereth, M., and M. Nilsson. Logical Foundations of Artificial Intelligence, Morgan Kaufman Publishers, 1998.
• Haaparanta, L. (ed.). Development of Modern Logic, New York: Oxford Unversity Press, 2009.
• Haaparanta, L. (ed.). Mind, Meaning and Mathematics, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1994.
• Haribhadra, S. Ṣaḍdarśana-samuccaya [with Guṇaratna's Commentary [ṢDS]], L. Suali (ed.), Kolkata: Asiatic Society, 1986.
• Jain, S. Jaina Bhāṣā Darśana [JBD], Delhi: Bhogilal Lehrchand Institute of Indology, 1986.
• Marathe, M. P, M. A. Kelkar, and P. P. Gokhale (eds.). Studies in Jainism [SIJQ], IPQ, IPQ Publications No. 7, University of Poona, India, 1984.
• Mardia, K. V. Jaina Logic and Statistical Concepts, Delhi: MLBD, 1975.
• Matilal, B. K. Central Philosophy of Jainism, Ahmedavad, India: L. D. Institute of Indology,1998.
• Mill, J. S. A System of Logic, (two volumes) first published 1843 (3rd-8th ed. 1874 with many changes, Longman, 1973.
• Mishra, A. Antarvyāpti, New Delhi: ICPR, 2002.
• Nyāyācārya, Pt. S. C. Jainadarśaner Digdarśana [in Bengali], Sanskrit College, Kolkata, 1975.
• Pandey, S. L. Nayavāda and Many-Valued Logic, 1984.
• Phaṇībhūṣaṇa, T. Nyāyadarśana, Vol. 1, Kolkata, India: Paschim Banga Rajya Pustak Parsad, 1989.
• Priest, G. Jaina Logic in Contemporary Perspective, In M. N. Mitra et al. (eds.), Studies in Logic: A Dialogue between the East and the West, 2012.
• Putnam, H. Representation and Reality, Harvard, Mass.: MIT Press, 1992.
• Quine, W. V. O. From a Logical point of View, New York: Harper Torch-Book, 1957.
• Ratnaprabhācārya's work. Ratnākarāvatārika [RAv], Ahmedavad: L. D. Bharatiya Sanskrit Vidyāmandir, 1968.
• Saha, S. R. (ed.). Essays in Indian Philosophy, Kolkata, India: Allied Publishers, 1997.
• Saha, S. R. Perspectives on Nyaya Logic and Epistemology, Kolkata: K. P. Bagchi & Co., 1987.
• Sarkar, T. K. Knowledge, Truth and Justification, Kolkata, India: Allied Publishers, 1992.
• Sarkar, T. K. Logics Beyond Consistency, 1998.
• Sarkar, T. K. Lectures on Jaina Philosophy of Language, Unpublished, Lectures Delivered at the Rabindra Bharati University, Kolkata, RBU, 2006.
• Sarkar, T. K. Indian Logic: Jaina Logic, Oxford University Press, 2009.
• Sarkar, T. K. Jaina Theory of Anumāna [Inference]: Some Aspects, Springer, 2021.
• Sarkar, T. K. Studies in Jaina Philosophy: Creating Dialogue with Western Philosophy. New Delhi: ICPR, 2023 (Forthcoming).
• Schang, F. Two Indian Dialectical Logics: Saptabhaṅgī and Catuṣkoṭi, JICPR XXVII (1), 2010.
• Sen, P. K. (ed). Logic, Identity and Consistency, Kolkata: Allied Publishers, 1998.
• Bhattacharya, S. Some Unique Features of Buddhist Logic, In S. R. Bhatt (ed.), Glimpses of Buddhist Thought and Culture, New Delhi: ICPR, 1984.
• Sinha, K. P. The Philosophy of Jainism. Kolkata: Punthi Pustak, 1990.
• Staal, F. The Concept of 'Pakṣa' in Indian Logic, Journal of Indian Philosophy 2, 1973, pp. 156-165.
• Vādideva, S. Pramāṇanayatattvālokālaṅkāra (PNTL), In H.S. Bhattacharya (ed), Jain Sāhitya Vikāś Maṇdal, Bombay, 1966.
• Vidyābhūṣaṇa, S. C. A History of Indian Logic, Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1978.
• Yaśovijaya, G. Jaina Tarkabhāṣā [JTB], Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass, 1973.

Identyfikatory

DOI

10.2478/sh-2023-0009