Planowanie przestrzenne w Polsce a aktualne kierunki w światowej dyskusji naukowej

• Autorzy: Maciej J. Nowak

Warianty tytułu

Spatial Planning in Poland and Current Directions in the Global Academic Discussion

• Języki publikacji: PL

Abstrakty

Celem artykułu jest wyodrębnienie kluczowych tez międzynarodowej dyskusji o wyzwaniach systemów planowania przestrzennego oraz odniesienie ich do polskiej debaty. W artykule w pierwszej kolejności odwołano się do tez, kluczowych w ocenie autora, międzynarodowych publikacji dotyczących debaty o planowaniu przestrzennym. Odnoszą się one do kierunków porównań systemów planowania przestrzennego oraz możliwości wspólnego zestawiania podobnych zagadnień planistycznych ujętych w regulacjach i praktyce różnych państw. Następnie skoncentrowano się na publikacjach odpowiadających na pytanie, w jaki sposób należy pogodzić planowanie przestrzenne z kluczowymi wyzwaniami dotyczącymi zmian klimatu. Poza ogólnym ujęciem, wyodrębniono osobne płaszczyzny tematyczne odnoszące się do odnawialnych źródeł energii i ochrony środowiska. W każdej ze wspomnianych płaszczyzn tematycznych można wyszczególnić istotne bariery oraz wyzwania stojące przed krajowymi systemami planowania przestrzennego. Powyższe tezy odniesiono do polskiej debaty naukowej o planowaniu przestrzennym. (abstrakt oryginalny)

EN

The objective of the article is to extract the key theses of the international discussion on the challenges of spatial planning systems and relate them to the Polish debate. The article first refers to the theses of international publications on the spatial planning debate, which the author considers key. They apply to the directions of comparisons of spatial planning systems and the possibility of jointly comparing similar planning issues contained in the regulations and practice of various countries. It then focuses on publications answering the question of how spatial planning should be reconciled with the key challenges of climate change. Other than a general overview, separate thematic planes regarding renewable energy sources and environmental protection have been identified. Significant barriers and challenges facing national spatial planning systems can be specified within each of these thematic planes. These theses were related to the Polish academic debate on spatial planning. (original abstract)

Słowa kluczowe

PL

Planowanie przestrzenne; Klimat; Zmiany klimatyczne; Odnawialne źródła energii

EN

Spatial planning; Climate; Climate change; Renewable energy sources

• Czasopismo: Samorząd Terytorialny
• Rocznik: 2023
• Numer: nr 10
• Strony: 11--22

Twórcy

autor

Maciej J. Nowak

• Zachodniopomorski Uniwersytet Technologiczny w Szczecinie

Bibliografia

• Agdahl H., The integration process of climate change adaptation for flood management in spatial planning: drawing examples from Älvstaden-Gothenburg between 1999-2015, Umeå 2017.
• Asarpota K., Nadin V., Energy Strategies, the Urban Dimension, and Spatial Planning, "Energies" 2020/13.
• Buuren A. van, Driessen P., van Rijswick M., Rietveld P., Salet W., Spit T., Teisman G., Towards Adaptive Spatial Planning for Climate Change: Balancing Between Robustness and Flexibility, "Journal for European Environmental & Planning Law" 2013/1.
• Byrne J., MacCallum D., Transgressing borders: Imagining environmental justice in spatial planning [w:] Planning Across Borders in a Climate of Change, red. W. Steele, T. Alizadeh, L. Eslami-Andargoli, S. Serrao-Neumann, Londyn 2014.
• Calvert K., Smit E., Wassmansdorf D., Smithers J., Energy Transition, Rural Transformation and Local Land-Use Planning: Insights from Ontario, Canada, "Environment and Planning E-Nature and Space" 2021/3.
• Cannas I., Lai S., Leone F., Zoppi C., Green infrastructure and ecological corridors: A regional study concerning Sardinia, "Sustainability" 2018/4.
• Christine F., Davide G., Integrating ecosystem services in spatial planning and strategic environmental assessment: The role of the cascade model, "Environmental Impact Assessment Review" 2019/78.
• Cowell R., Fischer T., Jackson T., Instituting space for the environment. How might we give the spatial demands of environmental policy goals a firm presence in the planning system? A think piece, Liverpool 2021.
• Davoudi S., Climate Change and the Role of Spatial Planning in England [w:] Climate Change Governance, red. J. Knieling, W. Filho, Berlin 2013.
• Dennis B., Greiving S., Climate and Demographic Change: The Need for an Integrative Approach to Spatial Planning in Germany, "Metropolitics" 2018, https://metropolitics.org/Climate-and-Demographic-Change-The-Need-for-an-Integrative-Approach-to-Spatial.html
• Douglas B., Marston G., McClure L., Synergies and goal conflicts for climate change policy and spatial planning [w:] REAL CORP 2013 - Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Urban Planning, Regional Development and Information Society, red. M. Schrenk, V. Popovich, P. Zeile, P. Elisei, Schwechat 2013.
• Fovargue R., Rezapour S., Rosendahl D., Wootten A., Sabzi H., Moreno H., Neeson T., Spatial planning for water sustainability projects under climate uncertainty: Balancing human and environmental water needs, "Environmental Research Letters" 2021/3.
• García A., Santé I., Loureiro X., Miranda D., Spatial Planning of Green Infrastructure for Mitigation and Adaptation to Climate Change at a Regional Scale, "Sustainability" 2020/12.
• Gedikli B., Approaches to climate change in spatial planning and design: international and Turkish experiences, "METU Journal of the Faculty of Architecture" 2018/1.
• Geissler S., Arevalo-Arizaga A., Radlbauer D., Wallisch P., Linking the National Energy and Climate Plan with Municipal Spatial Planning and Supporting Sustainable Investment in Renewable Energy Sources in Austria, "Energies" 2022/15.
• Gemenetzi G., Papageorgiou M., Spatial aspects of housing policy developed in the aftermath of the recent refugee crisis in Greece, "Proceedings of the International Conference on Changing Cities III: Spatial, Design, Landscape & Socio-Economic Dimensions", Mykonos 2017.
• Gustafsson S., Hermelin B., Smas L., Integrating environmental sustainability into strategic spatial planning: the importance of management, "Journal of Environmental Planning and Management" 2019/8.
• Hurlimann A., March A., The role of spatial planning in adapting to climate change, "WIREs Climate Change" 2012/3.
• Jonathan B., Climate Change Adaptation and Socio-ecological Justice in Chile's Metropolitan Areas: The Role of Spatial Planning Instruments [w:] Urbanization and Sustainability. Human-Environment Interactions, red. C.G. Boone, M. Fragkias, Dordrecht 2013.
• Josimović B., Cvjetić A., Furundžić D., Strategic Environmental Assessment and the precautionary principle in the spatial planning of wind farms - European experience in Serbia, "Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews" 2021/136.
• Junior P., Santos A.C., Mitigation and adaptation of cities to climate change: socio-environmental vulnerabilities and legal conflicts in the protection of urban Permanent Preservation Areas in Brazil, "Revista de Direito da Cidade" 2022/4.
• Klepinger M., Michigan Land Use Guidelines for Siting Wind Energy Systems, Michigan 2007.
• Lombardini G., Formal ontologies and strategic environmental assessment. A case study: the municipal land use plan of Genoa, "City, Territory and Architecture" 2016/1.
• Mascarenhas A., Ramos T., Haase D., Santos R., Ecosystem services in spatial planning and strategic environmental assessment - A European and Portuguese profile, "Land Use Policy" 2015/48.
• Markowski T., Teoria sprawiedliwości i interes publiczny jako podstawa budowania regulacyjnego systemu planowania przestrzennego: konceptualizacja problemu [w:] Badania miejskie i regionalne. Doświadczenia i perspektywy, red. F. Kuźnik, "Studia KPZK PAN" 2013/153.
• Markowski T., Nowak M., Współczesne trendy w rozwoju gospodarczym a potrzeba nowej doktryny urbanistycznej - w stronę elastyczności w planowaniu przestrzennym [w:] Polityka przestrzenna w czasie kryzysu, red. M. Nowak, Warszawa 2020.
• Moroni S., The Public Interest [w:] The Routledge Handbook of Planning Theory, red. M. Gundera, A. Madanipoura, V. Watson, Londyn 2017.
• Muñoz-Gielen D., Tasan Kok T., Flexibility in planning and the consequences for public value capturing in UK, Spain and the Netherlands, "European Planning Studies" 2010/18.
• Nadin V. i in., COMPASS - Comparative Analysis of Territorial Governance and Spatial Planning Systems in Europe Applied Research 2016-2018 Final Report, Luksemburg 2018.
• Planowanie i zagospodarowanie przestrzenne. Komentarz, red. H. Izdebski, I. Zachariasz, Warszawa 2023.
• Rehhausen A., Köppel J., Scholles F., Stemmer B., Syrbe R., Magel I., Wende W., Quality of federal level strategic environmental assessment. A case study analysis for transport, transmission grid and maritime spatial planning in Germany, "Environmental Impact Assessment Review" 2018/73.
• Reimer M., Getimis P., Blotevogel H., Spatial planning systems and practices in Europe: a comparative perspective [w:] Spatial planning systems and practices in Europe. A comparative perspective on continuity and changes, red. M. Reimer, P. Getimis, H. Blotevogel, Nowy Jork 2014.
• Rothwell A., Ridoutt B., Page G., Bellotti W., Feeding and housing the urban population: Environmental impacts at the peri-urban interface under different land-use scenarios, "Land Use Policy" 2015/48.
• Rozas-Vasquez D., Fuerst C., Geneletti D., Integrating ecosystem services in spatial planning and strategic environmental assessment: The role of the cascade model, "Environmental Impact Assesment Review" 2019/78.
• Segatto R., Vitale D., An Elaboration of the Land Use Plan in Relation to the Environmental Constraints. Social Demands [w:] Strategic Environmental Assessment and Urban Planning, red. G. Campeol, Cham 2020.
• Seto K., Shobhakar D., Bigio A., Blanco H., Delgado G., Dewar D., Huang L., Human Settlements, Infrastructure and Spatial Planning [w:] Climate Change 2014: Mitigation of Climate Change. Contribution of Working Group III to the Fifth Assessment Report of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, red. O. Edenhofer, R. Pichs-Madruga, Y. Sokona, E. Farahani, S. Kadner, K. Seyboth, A. Adler, Cambridge-Nowy Jork 2014.
• Stoeglehner G., Integrated Spatial and Energy Planning: A Means to Reach Sustainable Development Goals, "Evolutionary and Institutional Economics Review" 2020/17.
• Stoeglehner G., Neugebauer G., Erker S., Narodoslawsky M., Integrated Spatial and Energy Planning: Supporting Climate Protection and the Energy Turn with Means of Spatial Planning; Cham 2016.
• Sykes O., Shaw D., Webb B., International Planning Studies. An Introduction, Palgrave Macmillan 2023.
• Teschner N., Alterman R., Preparing the ground: Regulatory challenges in siting small-scale wind turbines in urban areas, "Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews" 2018/2.
• Thoidou E., Spatial Planning and Climate Adaptation: Challenges of Land Protection in a Peri-Urban Area of the Mediterranean City of Thessaloniki, "Sustainability" 2021/8.
• Thornley A., Newman P., International competition, urban governance and planning projects: Malmö, Birmingham and Lille, "European Planning Studies" 1996/4.
• Wiehe J., Haaren C. von, Walter A., How to Achieve the Climate Targets? Spatial Planning in the Context of the German Energy Transition, "Energy, Sustainability and Society" 2020/10.
• Wilson E., Piper J., Spatial Planning and Climate Change, London 2010.
• Yiannakou A., Salata K., Adaptation to climate change through spatial planning in compact urban areas: A case study in the City of Thessaloniki, "Sustainability" 2017/9.
• Zhan-Yun W., Integrating adaptation to climate change into territorial spatial planning: progress, dilemma and strategy, "Climate Change Research" 2021/5.