Two New Interpretation of Plato's Protagoras

• Autorzy: Sana Javanmardi , Saeed Binaaye Motlaq
• Języki publikacji: EN

Abstrakty

EN

As we know, one of the most important ideas of Protagoras is Epistemic Relativism that this theory is attributed to him during the history of philosophy, without any dispute; But in the new era commentators such as Dr. Qavam Safari and Cornford by further and more precise reading the conversations between Protagoras and Theaetetus have concluded to this belief that Plato has interpreted the Protagoras' rule of "Humanism", by assimilating it with a course which he calls it "secret" and also the theory of Theaetetus "knowledge = perceiving", in a way that it leads to perfect and very sophisticated relativism; and then in an ahistorical effort, Plato has imposed this relativism to the Protagoras' mind. Whether this claim is proved or remained only as a claim, it should be discussed; so we have attempted to address this important issue in the present article. (original abstract)

Słowa kluczowe

EN

Philosophy; History of philosophy; History

PL

Filozofia; Historia filozofii; Historia

• Czasopismo: International Letters of Social and Humanistic Sciences (ILSHS)
• Rocznik: 2014
• Tom: 13
• Strony: 12--25

Twórcy

autor

Sana Javanmardi

• University of Isfahan, Iran

autor

Saeed Binaaye Motlaq

• University of Isfahan, Iran

Bibliografia

• [1] Aristotle, Metaphysics, translated by Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Tarh-e-nov Publication, Tehran, (2006).
• [2] Barnes, Johnathan, The Presocratic Philosophers, Routledge, London, (1989).
• [3] Copleston, Frederick, Volume 1, History of Greek and Roman philosophy, Translated by Seyyed Jalal al-Din Mojtabavi, Edition 4, Tehran: Cultural and Scientific Publishing Co and Soroush Press, (2001).
• [4] Cornford, F. M., Plato's Theory of Knowledge, fifth impression, Routledge & Kegan Paul, London, (1960).
• [5] Diels, H. and Kranz, Ancilla to the Pre-Socratic Philosophers, A complete translation of the Fragments in Diels Fragment der Vorsokratiker by: Kathleen Freeman, Cambrifge, Massachusetts: Harvrd University press, (1948).
• [6] Durant, William James, History of Civilization, Volume 2, A group of translators, Tehran: Teaching Islamic Revolution, (1991).
• [7] Foroughi, M. A, Development of Philosophy in Europe, Alborz Publication, Tehran, (1996).
• [8] Guthrie, W. K.C, History of Greek Philosophy, Vol 2: Anaximander & Anoximenes, Translated by Hassan Fathy, Fekr-e-rouz publications, (1996).
• [9] Guthrie, W. K.C, History of Greek Philosophy, Vol 10: Sophists (Part One), Translated by Hassan Fathy, Fekr-e-rouz publications, (1996).
• [10] Guthrie, W. K.C, History of Greek Philosophy, Vol 11: Sophists (Part Two), Translated by Hassan Fathy, Fekr-e-rouz publications, (1996).
• [11] Guthrie, W. K. C, A History of Greek Philosophy, Volume One, Cambridge University Press, London, (1962).
• [12] Guthrie, W. K. C, A History of Greek Philosophy, Volume Three, Cambridge University Press, London, (1969).
• [13] Holling, Dale, R. J, Principles and History of Western Philosophy, Translated by Abdal-Hossain Azarang, Keyhan Publication, Tehran, (1997).
• [14] Jaeger, Werner, Paideia, Translated by Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Volume 1, Khwarizmi Publishing Company, Tehran, (1997).
• [15] Jaeger, Werner , Paideia, Translated by Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Volume 2, Khwarizmi Publishing Company, Tehran, (1997).
• [16] Kerferd G.B., The Sophists. Routledge History of Philosophy 1 (1997) 225-245.
• [17] Mahdavi, Y, Skeptics of Greece, Khwarizmi Publication, Tehran, (1997).
• [18] McDowell, John, Plato, Theaetetus, Translated with notes, Seventh impression, Oxford, (1991).
• [19] Motahari, M., Philosophy and Realism, volume 1, Sadra, Tehran, (1993).
• [20] Plato, Protagoras, Translated with Notes by C.C.W. Taylor, fell of corpus Christi College Oxford University Press, (2002).
• [21] Plato, Period of Plato's work, Volume 1, translated by Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Third edition, Tehran: Khwarizmi Publishing Company, (2001).
• [22] Plato, Period of Plato's work, Volume 2, translated by Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Third edition, Tehran: Khwarizmi Publishing Company, (2001).
• [23] Plato, Period of Plato's work, Volume 3, translated by Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Third edition, Tehran: Khwarizmi Publishing Company, (2001).
• [24] Plato, Period of Plato's work, Volume 4, translated by Mohammad Hassan Lotfi, Third edition, Tehran: Khwarizmi Publishing Compan, (2001).
• [25] Qavam Safari M., "Plato's Ahistorical interpretation of Protagoras' Theory of Humanism ", Zehn Journal 10 (2002) 56-27.
• [26] Saneii Darreh Bidi, M., Foundations of Philosophical Thought (General Philosophy), Tehran: Amir Kabir institute press, (2005).
• [27] Takrini, Najy, Platonic moral philosophy, First Edition, Baghdad: Andalusia, (1979 AD).
• [28] Theodor, Gomperz, Greek thinkers, Volume 1, Translated by Mohammad Lotfi, Tehran: Khwarizmi Publishing Company, (1996).