Monitoring and Analysis of the Risk of the Commercial Real Estate Sector in Poland : Data Sources, Methodology and Empirical Results

• Autorzy: Krzysztof Olszewski , Krystyna Gałaszewska , Andrzej Jakubowski , Robert Leszczyński , Hanna Żywiecka
• Języki publikacji: EN

Abstrakty

EN

This paper shows how Narodowy Bank Polski analyses the commercial property market in Poland and monitors risks that it can generate for the financial sector and the whole economy. This market is crucial for the functioning of the modern economy, but it has also led to economic and financial crises in many countries. Especially under the very low interest rates in the euro zone, a lot of capital flows into the commercial real estate market. A holistic approach to its analysis is needed. We present a hedonic rent index for office and retail properties in two major cities and a transaction price index for the office market and the retail market in the whole country. Commercial real estate is very heterogenous, therefore we need to apply hedonic regressions to obtain reliable price and rent indices. For this purpose we also describe which data about commercial real estate rents and prices and information about their determinants is collected and how this is done. Finally, we present an analysis of the profitability of an office space investment, which helps to understand the situation of investors and also to make a simple stress test of the rate of return, which accounts for increasing interest rates and/or vacancy rates.(original abstract)

Słowa kluczowe

EN

Financial sector; Real estate market; Commercial property; Risk; Regression analysis; Return on Investment (ROI)

PL

Sektor finansowy; Rynek nieruchomości; Nieruchomości komercyjne; Ryzyko; Analiza regresji; Stopa zwrotu kapitału

• Czasopismo: Bank i Kredyt
• Rocznik: 2019
• Numer: nr 6
• Strony: 571--603

Twórcy

autor

Krzysztof Olszewski

• Narodowy Bank Polski

autor

Krystyna Gałaszewska

• Narodowy Bank Polski, Regional Branch in Gdańsk

autor

Andrzej Jakubowski

• Narodowy Bank Polski, Regional Branch in Warsaw

autor

Robert Leszczyński

• Narodowy Bank Polski, Regional Branch in Białystok

autor

Hanna Żywiecka

• Narodowy Bank Polski, Regional Branch in Poznań

Bibliografia

• Bollinger C.R., Ihlanfeldt K.R., Bowes D.R. (1998), Spatial variation in office rents within the Atlanta region,Urban Studies, 35(7), 1097-1118.
• Chegut A.M., Eichholtz P.M., Rodrigues P.J. (2015), Spatial dependence in international office markets, The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 51(2), 317-350.
• Deryol E. (2019), A hedonic analysis of price movements in commercial properties in the retail sector, paper presented at the International Conference on Real Estate Statistics, 20-22 February, Luxembourg.
• Deryol E., Konukçu D., Szemere R., Tissot B. (2019), Mind the data gap: commercial property prices for policy, IFC Report, March, Bank for International Settlements.
• Deschermeier P., Voigtländer M., Seipelt B. (2014), Modelling a hedonic index for commercial properties in Berlin, Conference Paper for the European Real Estate Society.
• Diewert W.E., Heravi S., Silver M. (2009), Hedonic imputation versus time dummy hedonic indexes, in: W.E. Diewert, J.S. Greenlees, Ch.R. Hulten (eds.), Price Index Concepts and Measurement, University of Chicago Press.
• Duca J.V., Ling D.C. (2018), The other (commercial) real estate boom and bust: the effects of risk premia and regulatory capital arbitrage, Journal of Banking & Finance, in press.
• Dwyer-Bond E., Casey B., Coates D. (2019), Developing data sources for a Commercial Property Statistical System (CPSS) in Ireland, paper presented at the International Conference on Real Estate Statistics, 20-22 February, Luxembourg.
• ECB (2008), Commercial property market - financial stability, recent developments and EU banks' exposures, December.
• ECB (2010), Euro area commercial property markets and their impact on banks, ECB Monthly Bulletin, February.
• ECB (2011), Indicators for detecting possible value misalignments in commercial property markets, Financial Stability Review, Box 3, December.
• Ellis L., Naughtin C. (2010), Commercial property and financial stability - an international perspective,RBA Bulletin, June, 25-30.
• ESRB (2015), Report on Commercial Real Estate and Financial Stability in the EU, European Systemic Risk Board.
• ESRB (2018), Report on Vulnerabilities in the EU Commercial Real Estate Sector, European Systemic Risk Board.
• Eurostat (2017), Commercial property price indicators: sources, methods and issues: 2017 edition, Eurostat.
• Evangelista R., Moreira H., Teixeira Â. (2019), On the derivation of hedonic rental price indexes for commercial properties: rent price determinants, data quality problems and evidence from the use, paper presented at the International Conference on Real Estate Statistics, 20-22 February, Luxembourg.
• Fisher J., Geltner D., Pollakowski H. (2007), A quarterly transactions-based index of institutional real estate investment performance and movements in supply and demand, The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 34(1), 5-33.
• Fuerst F. (2008), Office rent determinants: a hedonic panel analysis, Working Papers in Real Estate & Planning, Working Paper, 12/08, University of Reading.
• Geltner D., Miller N.G., Clayton J., Eichholtz P. (2001), Commercial Real Estate Analysis and Investments, South-Western Educational Publication.
• Gerbich M. (1998), Shopping centre rentals: an empirical analysis of the retail tenant mix,Journal of Real Estate Research, 15(3), 283-296.
• de Haan J., Diewert W.E. (2011), Handbook on Residential Property Price Indexes, Eurostat.
• Hiebert P., Wredenborg S. (2012), Commercial property analysis: an ECB perspective, presentation at the Joint BIS - ECB - Eurostat - IMF - OECD international conference on "Commercial property price indicators", European Central Bank.
• Łaszek J., Leszczyński R., Olszewski K. (2017), The development of residential and commercial real estate, and economic development in Polish voivodships, Barometr Regionalny, 15(2), 19-33.
• Łaszek J., Widłak M. (2008), Badanie cen na rynku mieszkań prywatnych zamieszkałych przez właściciela z perspektywy banku centralnego, Bank i Kredyt, 8, 12-41.
• Leszczyński R., Olszewski K. (2015), Commercial property price index for Poland, Bank i Kredyt, 6, 565-578.
• Mølskov C., Jensen S.K. (2019), Combining administrative and market data in the development of new commercial real estate indicators, paper presented at the International Conference on Real Estate Statistics, 20-22 February, Luxembourg.
• NBP (2018a), Rynek nieruchomości: badanie cen nieruchomości mieszkaniowych i komercyjnych w wybranych miastach Polski (ankieta), Narodowy Bank Polski http://www.nbp.pl/home.aspx?f=/ publikacje/rynek_nieruchomosci/ankieta.html.
• NBP (2018b), Report on the situation in the Polish residential real estate market in 2017, Narodowy Bank Polski.
• Nehrebecka N., Widłak M. (2012), Zróżnicowanie cen mieszkań a ograniczenia budżetowe nabywców, Kwartalnik Nauk o Przedsiębiorstwie, 1, 99-106.
• Olszewski K. (2013), The commercial real estate market, central bank monitoring and macroprudential policy,Review of Economic Analysis, 5(2), 213-250.
• Olszewski K., Decyk P., Gałaszewska K., Jakubowski A., Kulig M., Modzelewska R., Żywiecka H. (2018), Hedonic analysis of office and retail rents in three major cities in Poland, in: J. Łaszek, K. Olszewski, R. Sobiecki (eds.), Recent Trends in the Real Estate Market and its Analysis, Oficyna Wydawnicza SGH.
• Olszewski K., Waszczuk J., Widłak M. (2017), Spatial and hedonic analysis of house price dynamics in Warsaw, Poland, Journal of Urban Planning and Development, 143(3).
• Quigley J.M. (1999), Real estate prices and economic cycles, International Real Estate Review, 2(1), 1-20.
• Raposo I.G., Evangelista R. (2016), A transactions-based commercial property price index for Portugal, Financial Stability Papers, 4, Banco de Portugal.
• Rosen S. (1974), Hedonic prices and implicit markets: product differentiation in pure competition, Journal of Political Economy, 82(1), 34 -55.
• Silver M. (2019), Data sources for CPPIs: an overview and strategy, paper presented at the International Conference on Real Estate Statistics, 20-22 February, Luxembourg.
• Sirmans C., Guidry K. (1993), The determinants of shopping centre rents, Journal of Real Estate Research, 8(1), 107-115.
• Tomczyk E., Widłak M. (2010), Konstrukcja i własności hedonicznego indeksu cen mieszkań dla Wa rszawy,Bank i Kredyt, 41(1), 99-128.
• Trojanowski D., Olszewski K., Gałaszewska K. (2018), The robustness of office building investment in the low interest rate environment, in: J. Łaszek, K. Olszewski, R. Sobiecki (eds.), Recent Trends in the Real Estate Market and its Analysis, Oficyna Wydawnicza SGH.
• Ustaoglu E., Türel A., Güzel A. (2013), Evaluating the functional utility characteristics of office buildings: a case study of the office market in Ankara, Turkey, Journal of Real Estate Literature, 21(1), 79-103.
• Wheaton W.C. (1999), Real estate"cycles": some fundamentals, Real Estate Economics, 27(2), 209-230.
• Widłak M. (2010a), Dostosowanie indeksów cenowych do zmian jakości. Metoda wyznaczania hedonicznych indeksów cen i możliwości ich zastosowania dla rynku mieszkaniowego, Materiały iStudia NBP, 247, Narodowy Bank Polski.
• Widłak M. (2010b), Metody wyznaczania hedonicznych indeksów cen jako sposób kontroli zmian jakości dóbr, Wiadomości Statystyczne, 9(592), 1-26.
• Widłak M., Tomczyk E. (2010), Measuring price dynamics: evidence from the Warsaw housing market, Journal of European Real Estate Research, 3(3), 203-227.