On interaction of the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation to ensure case law integrity

• Autorzy: Igor' Yrevitz Ostapovič , Jacek Zaleśny

Warianty tytułu

O relacjach Sądu Konstytucyjnego i Sądu Najwyższego w Federacji Rosyjskiej w zakresie ujednolicania praktyki sądowej

• Języki publikacji: EN

Abstrakty

EN

The article discusses the problem of interaction of the Constitutional Court and the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation with respect to case law integrity. The authors present a hypothesis that the merge of the Supreme Arbitration Court and the Supreme Court in the single Supreme Court will improve the interaction between the Constitutional Court and the other courts, including in the field of achieving case law integrity. The uniform case law is considered to be either an essential component and the result of judicial activity or the result of identical qualification of similar cases, and a form of judicial control. The uniform case law should be aimed at promoting the rule of law. (original abstract)

W artykule poddano analizie kwestie interakcji zachodzących między Sądem Konstytucyjnym i Sądem Najwyższym Federacji Rosyjskiej, w kontekście jednolitości orzecznictwa sądów. Autorzy stawiają hipotezę, że ujednoliceniu orzecznictwa sądowego i poprawie współpracy między Sądem Konstytucyjnym i innymi sądami służyłoby połączenie Naczelnego Sądu Arbitrażowego oraz Sądu Najwyższego w Sąd Najwyższy. Dzięki tej zmianie organizacyjnej można byłoby realizować wartość ustrojową w postaci poprawy efektywności działalności sądowej i spójnego rozstrzygania przez sądy w podobnych sprawach. Z kolei jednolitość orzecznictwa sądowego powinna służyć promowaniu rządów prawa. (abstrakt oryginalny)

Słowa kluczowe

EN

Supreme Court; Judicial decision

PL

Sąd Najwyższy; Orzecznictwo sądu

• Czasopismo: Ius Novum
• Rocznik: 2017
• Tom: 11
• Numer: nr 2
• Strony: 7--16

Twórcy

autor

Igor' Yrevitz Ostapovič

• Gorno-Altaisk State University, Russian Federation

autor

Jacek Zaleśny

• University of Warsaw Poland

Bibliografia

• Братусь С.Н., Венгеров А.Б., Понятие, содержание и формы судебной практики, [в:] С.Н. Братусь (ред.), Судебная практика в советской правовой системе, Москва 1975 [S.N. Bratus, A.B. Vengerov, Case law concept, content, and forms, [in:] S.N. Bratus (ed.), Case law in Soviet legal system, Moscow 1975].
• Витрук Н.В., Конституционное правосудие: судебное конституционное право и процесс, Москва 2011 [N.V. Vitruk, The constitutional justice: Judicial constitutional law and proceedings, Moscow 2011].
• Гаджиев Г.А., Закон "О Конституционном Суде Российской Федерации": новеллы конституционного судопроизводства 2010 г., Журнал российского права № 10, 2011 [G.A. Gadzhiyev, The Law "On Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation": Novelisations of constitutional judicial process 2010, Russian Juridical Journal No. 10, 2011].
• Ершов В.В., Правовая природа правовых позиций суда, Российское правосудие № 6 (86), 2013 [V.V. Ershov, The legal nature of the legal positions of courts, Russian Justice No. 6 (86), 2013].
• Ершов В.В., Судебная власть и правосудие в Российской Федерации, Москва 2011 [V.V. Ershov, The judicial power and justice in the Russian Federation, Moscow 2011].
• Ершова Е.А., Корнев В.Н., Прямое применение Конституции к трудовым отношениям: современные проблемы теории и практики, Российское правосудие № 6 (74), 2012, [E.A. Ershova, V.N. Kornev, Direct application of the Constitution to labour relations: Modern theory and practice, Russian Justice No. 6 (74), 2012].
• Жуйков В.М., Роль разъяснений Пленума Верховного Суда Российской Федерации в обеспечении единства судебной практики и защиты прав человека, [в:] В.М. Жуйков (ред.), Комментарий к постановлениям Пленума Верховного Суда Российской Федерации по гражданским делам, Москва 2008 [V.M. Zhuykov, The role of clarification of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation in ensuring the unity of the case law and human rights protection, [in:] V.M. Zhuykov (ed.), Commentaries to the resolutions of the Plenum of the Supreme Court in civil cases, Moscow 2008].
• Замотаева Е.К., Судебное нормотворчество как фактор динамики и стабильности законодательства, [в:] Закон: стабильность и динамика, мат-лы заседания Международной школы-практикума молодых ученых-юристов, Москва 2007 [E.K. Zamotayeva, Judicial lawmaking as a factor of legislative dynamics and stability, [in:] Law: Stability and dynamics, materials of the meeting of the International School-Workshop of Young Legal Scholars, Moscow 2007].
• Калиновский К.Б., Конституционный Суд следователю не указ?!, Уголовный процесс № 10, 2011 [K.B. Kalinowskiy, Investigators do not take orders from the Constitutional Court?!, Criminal Procedure No. 10, 2011].
• Кряжков В.А., Законодательная модернизация статуса Конституционного Суда Российской Федерации, Конституционное и муниципальное право № 10, 2011 [V.A. Kryazhkov, The legislative modernization of the status of the Russian Federation Constitutional Court, Constitutional and Municipal Law No. 10, 2011].
• Лазарев Л.В., Правовые позиции Конституционного Суда России, Москва 2003 [L.V. Lazarev, The legal positions of the Constitutional Court of Russia, Moscow 2003].
• Лазарев Л.В., Морщакова Т.Г., Страшун Б.А., Конституция Российской Федерации в решениях Конституционного Суда России, Москва 2005 [L.V. Lazarev, T.G. Morshchakova, B.A. Strashun, The Constitution of the Russian Federation in the decisions of the Constitutional Court of Russia, Moscow 2005].
• Малько А.В. (ред.), Краткий юридический словарь, Москва 2008 [A.V. Malko (ed.), Small Dictionary of Law, Moscow 2008].
• Муратова Н.Г., Единство судебной практики: исторические предпосылки и современные тенденции, [в:] Н.А. Колоколов (ред.), Уголовное судопроизводство: теория и практика, Москва 2011 [N.G. Muratova, Case law unity: Historical background and modern trends, [in:] N.A. Kolokolov (ed.), Criminal proceedings: Theory and practice, Moscow 2011].
• Осокина Г.Л., Гражданский процесс. Особенная часть, Москва 2007 [G.L. Osokina, Civil procedure. Special part, Moscow 2007].
• Саликов М.С., Новеллы конституционного судебного процесса, Российский юридический журнал № 4, 2011 [M.S. Salikov, Novelisations of constitutional judicial process, Russian Juridical Journal No. 4, 2011].
• Смоленский М.Б., Конституционное (государственное) право России, Ростов 2007 [M.B. Smolenskiy, The Constitutional (State) law of Russia, Rostov 2007].
• Эбзеев Б.С., Конституционный Суд России: правовая природа и функции, [в:] Конституционное правосудие в Российской Федерации и Германии: материалы круглого стола 9-10 октября 2012 года, Москва 2013 [B.S. Ebzeyev, The Constitutional Court of Russia: Legal nature and functions, [in:] Constitutional justice in the Russian Federation and Germany: Materials of the Round Table held on 9-10 October 2012, Moscow 2013].
• Arbitration Procedure Code of the Russian Federation dated 24 July 2002, No. 95-FL (as amended on 6 April 2015), Rossiyskaya Gazeta No. 137, 27 July 2002.
• Civil Procedure Code of the Russian Federation dated 14 November 2002, No. 138-FL (as amended on 6 April 2015), Rossiyskaya Gazeta No. 220, 20 November 2002.
• Code of Administrative Court Procedure of the Russian Federation dated 8 March 2015, No. 21-FL (as amended on 3 July 2016.), Rossiyskaya Gazeta No. 49, 11 March 2015.
• Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation dated 18 December 2001, No. 174-FL (as amended on 30 March 2015), Rossiyskaya Gazeta No. 249, 22 December 2001.
• Federal Constitutional Law of the Russian Federation "On the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation" No. 3-FKZ dated 5 February 2014.
• Resolution of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation No. 6-P dated 16 May 2007 in the case concerning the revision of constitutionality of Articles 237, 413, and 418 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation upon request of the Presidium of the Kurgan Regional Court, Rossiyskaya Gazeta, 12 May 2007.
• Resolution of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation No. 1-P dated 31 January 2011, Saint Petersburg, "On the case regarding the review of the constitutionality of provisions of the first, third and ninth parts of Article 115, clause 2 of the first part of Article 208 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation, and the ninth paragraph of clause 1 of Article 126 of the Federal Law 'On insolvency (bankruptcy)' in response to complaints of 'Nedvizhimost-M' closed joint-stock company, 'Solomatinsk Grain Receival Station' limited liability company, and Ms L.I. Kostareva (L.I. Kostareva Case)", Rossiyskaya Gazeta No. 5405, 11 February 2011.
• Resolutions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation in L.I. Kostareva Case No. 9-P dated 28 May 1999.
• Resolutions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation in L.I. Kostareva Case No. 3-P dated 21 March 2007.
• Resolutions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation in L.I. Kostareva Case No. 1-P dated 17 January 2008.
• Resolutions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation in L.I. Kostareva Case No. 6-P dated 25 March 2008.
• Resolutions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation in L.I. Kostareva Case No. 9-P dated 16 July 2008.
• Resolutions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation in L.I. Kostareva Case No. 4-P dated 26 February 2010.
• Rulings of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation in L.I. Kostareva Case No. 614-O-O dated 17 July 2007.
• Rulings of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation in L.I. Kostareva Case No. 246-O-O dated 20 March 2008.
• Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 5 dated 11 February 2007 "On amendments to certain resolutions of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation concerning judicial activity", Bulletin of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 3, 2007.
• Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 9 dated 16 April 2013 "On Amendments to the Resolution of the Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 8 dated 31 October 1995 'On certain issues of application of the Constitution of the Russian Federation by the courts in the administration of justice'", Bulletin of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 5, 2013.
• Resolution of the Presidium of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 128P13 dated 25 September 2013, Bulletin of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 2, 2014.
• Resolution of the Presidium of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 315-P13PR dated 25 December 2013.
• Ruling of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation No. 250-O dated 7 February 2013 "Regarding the complaint of Ms Kostareva, Lyudmila Ivanovna, concerning the violation of the constitutional rights by provisions of the ninth part of Article 115 and Article 154 of the Criminal Procedure Code of the Russian Federation", Law Reference System Pravo: http://docs.pravo.ru/document/view/67159310 (application date: 04.04.2015).
• Ruling of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation No. 307-KG14-4737 dated 21 April 2015, available at: http://base.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/online.cgi?req=doc;base=ARB; n=424834 (application date: 24.11.2016).